Herd mentality is the tendency for people’s behavior or beliefs to conform
to those of the group they belong to. The concept of herd mentality has
been studied and analyzed from different perspectives, including biology,
psychology and sociology. This psychological phenomenon can have profound
impacts on human behavior. Social psychologists study the related topics of
collective intelligence, crowd wisdom, groupthink, and deindividuation.
The earth and space were so natural long ago. There are populations
of species living together. Agni was a tool for utility purposes which
burnt unwanted things as a waste to be recycled by the earth. Trees and
creepers yielded food for survival. Caves and wooden natural structures
protected from weather. Fibers gave coverages of the body and to
manufacture work must be exerted. It in turn maintained the earth
naturality as well as the Pancha Bhutas of the body. Water was every
whereas forest naturally gave the rain. Trees were the school buildings.
Knowledge then was amazing which the modern facilities reduced all to ashes
the Agni burnt called pollutants. Nature is dead. ALL THE SCIENCE OLDEN
DAYS HAVE BECOME MYTH TO DAY AND THE FUTURE MYTHS ARE NAMED MODERN SCIENCE.
Herds’ instinct started to pollute more.
The idea of a "group mind" or "mob behavior" was first put forward by
19th-century social psychologists Gabriel Tarde and Gustave Le Bon. Herd
behavior in human societies has also been studied by Sigmund Freud and
Wilfred Trotter, whose book Instincts of the Herd in Peace and War is a
classic in the field of social psychology. Sociologist and economist
Thorstein Veblen's The Theory of the Leisure Class illustrates how
individuals imitate other group members of higher social status in their
consumer behavior. More recently, Malcolm Gladwell in The Tipping Point,
examines how cultural, social, and economic factors converge to create
trends in consumer behavior. In 2004, the New Yorker's financial columnist
James Surowiecki published The Wisdom of Crowds.
A naive participant was put in a room with seven confederates (i.e.
actors) who had agreed in advance to match their responses. The participant
was not aware of this and was told that the actors were also naive
participants. There was one control condition with no confederates.
Confederates purposefully gave the wrong answer on 12 trials. The other
participant usually went with the group and said the wrong answer.Through
18 trials total, Asch (1951) found that one third (33%) of naive
participants conformed with the clearly incorrect majority, with 75% of
participants over the 12 trials. Fewer than 1% of participants gave the
wrong answer when there were no confederates.Researchers at Leeds
University performed a group experiment in which volunteers were told to
randomly walk around a large hall without talking to each other. A select
few were then given more detailed instructions on where to walk. The
scientists discovered that people end up blindly following one or two
instructed people who appear to know where they are going. The results of
this experiment showed that it only takes 5% of confident looking and
instructed people to influence the direction of the other 95% of people in
the crowd, and the 200 volunteers did this without even realizing it.
Researchers from Hebrew University, NYU, and MIT explored herd mentality in
online spaces, specifically in the context of "digitized, aggregated
opinions." Online comments were given an initial positive or negative vote
(up or down) on an undisclosed website over five months. The control group
comments were left alone. The researchers found that "the first person
reading the comment was 32% more likely to upvote it if it had been already
given a fake positive score."[8] Over the five months, comments
artificially rated positively showed a 25% higher average score than the
control group, with the initial negative vote ending up with no statistical
significance in comparison to the control group. The researchers found that
"prior ratings created significant bias in individual rating behavior, and
positive and negative social influences created asymmetric herding effects."
Evidence of herding in animals, especially monkeys, humankind’s closest
relatives suggests that herd mentality has evolutionary roots. Evidence
shows that animals acquire information to make important decisions (i.e.
where to forage and mating potential) by monitoring the interactions of
others with their environment. For instance, imitation in monkeys is the
most effective strategy of rapidly transmitting information throughout the
species. Accumulating evidence and statistical hypotheses framework
developed using a Markov chain approach has shown that the joint
exploitation of one source will give more benefit to the group than an even
distribution of effort over two different sources. In humans, evidence
suggests that conformity is the product of both informational and normative
influences, where the latter refers to receptivity to intra-group social
pressures. Social scientists have regarded this as an important
evolutionary instinct which encourages socially constructive empathy and
altruism, helpful in overcoming conflict. The advantages conferred to herd
behavior has led to it shaping human evolution, consistent with Darwin’s
theory of natural selection. Herd behavior can also be illuminated by
neuroscience. Recent developments in neuroscience suggest that our tendency
to ‘imitate’ might be due to a system of ‘mirror neurons’ in our brains. In
an experiment that recorded electrical activity in the brain of a macaque,
it was found that the same neurons fired both when the monkey acted and
when the monkey observed the same action performed by the other. The neuron
‘mirrored’ the motor behavior of the other, as though the observer was
executing the motor act. It is hypothesized that there is a similar ‘mirror
neuron’ network that exists in human brains but has yet to be proven
because of the ethical considerations surrounding experimentation.
‘Docility’, or receptivity to social norms is a fundamental
characteristic that underlies herd behavior. Research done on cognitive
psychology has shown that humans differ from other species in the
development of social norms and mutually shared expectations which inform
them about what actions are normal, appropriate or just given any
situation. The Asch experiment where subjects conformed to the erroneous
majority view, has shown that the human mind is built to be receptive to
social norms and self-censor actions in advance to avoid deviations from
the norm. ‘Docility’ is also created by the human response to narratives
and stories, by which most information is conveyed, which influences people
to view, interpret and see things from a shared viewpoint.
Trading in financial markets is characterized by herd behavior to a
large extent. In times of market uncertainty, fear response drives
investors to imitate what other investors are doing without conducting
their own analysis to mitigate the risk of failure. Economist Keynes states
that ‘worldly wisdom teaches that it is better for reputation to fail
conventionally than to succeed unconventionally’. Unjustified runs on
foreign exchange currencies and stock market bubbles are usually
attributable to herding behavior At other times, individuals benefit from
the ‘information cascade’ by herding to piece together incomplete
information about the market. Nonetheless, the arbitrary nature of
decision-making in the financial markets based on herding can generate
large-scale instability.
Herd mentality can be harnessed as a useful tool in marketing (i.e.
influencers and reviews) as studies have found that shoppers are more
inclined to purchase a product when their attitude is framed by others’
influence and that herd mentality becomes more apparent as the group size
grows. Nonetheless, herd behavior on social media can also create
dangerous echo chambers and lead to the polarization of society. When
people do not challenge the status quo or express dissenting opinions, it
might create an echo-chamber environment where a person only encounters
information that reflects and reinforces their own. Where members of a
societal group adopt homogenous opinions, it amplifies the group’s
collective beliefs and might result in the marginalization of minority
viewpoints and a potential for group members to prioritize consensus over
rational decision-making (known as ‘group think’.
K Rajaram IRS 1725
On Tue, 1 Jul 2025 at 06:25, Markendeya Yeddanapudi <
[email protected]> wrote:
>
>
> --
> *Mar**Air Poisoning and Cowardice*
>
>
>
> When you are inspired you take a deep breath. When you are determined, you
> inhale deeply but do not exhale completely fast. You exhale slowly your
> determination into the air and the other organisms inhale the smell
> message. The air reinforces your determination, the cascades of symbiosis
> giving you the strength needed for dermination.Nature always reinforces the
> symbiotic determination. By breathing deeply, you are actually getting the
> smell messages of strength from the organisms of the Biosphere.
>
> But the air must not be polluted and poisoned. When you breathe in the
> poisonous fumes, you hesitate and then breathe very haltingly, often
> suspending breathing. You develop the fear to breathe. Fear to breathe is
> the chronic symptom of cowardice. You become the chronic coward. You do not
> get the inspiring smell messages from the other organisms of the Biosphere.
> Air pollutions wounds one at the very core, corrodes courage.
>
> A coward takes advantage of the helplessness of others including the other
> organisms. A coward always wants to dominate if he can. Cowardice makes one
> hide and bluff. Often a coward concocts lies about you, negative things,
> and tells them to others behind you. One fact of Psychology is, when a
> person tells negative things about someone to you behind that person, then
> be definite that he will tell negative things about you to someone else in
> your absence.
>
> In free, lush and thick nature, breathing means getting informed.
> Automatically it gives the power to sense the future. Uncertainty is
> greatly reduced, as breathing gives the flow of confidence. It is the basic
> lifeline of courage. Even today, where there is some free nature surviving,
> you can get confidence and hope and reduce depression by inhaling deeply.
> Future appears as a clear road to follow.
>
> Unfortunately we are somehow surviving in the present era of mass
> fooling—advertising, marketing and media brain washing. Panic ridden
> shouting has become expression.
>
> When nature was free, lush and thick God was everywhere, and one inhaled
> God. Today, thanks to advertizing and the marketing of poisoned and
> attractively packaged foods, and brainwashing continuously, God has gone
> and people are made to fear nature as it is supposedly hiding many harmful
> bacteria. The facts that for every single cell of the seven octillion cells
> of you, there are ten bacteriums in your body, making you alive, that right
> in each cell there are the power generating bacteria, the mitochondria,
> giving the active photons in you, making you live, are simply kept
> sidelined. You get the dettol lullabies’ of the mother to the child.
> Advertizing has become mass fooling. Under our feet there is the soil
> bacteria using the nerve connections in the heels to create basic symbiosis
> in living ecologically, not economically or mechanically without feeling.
>
> When nature was free, lush and thick every organism could sense the mood
> of the other organisms by smelling and sensing. One could go very near the
> very cruel animals as one knew the mood of that animal. Today, at the very
> sight of a lion or tiger one simply gets terror stricken.
>
> What sort of education is it that it does not give the power of sensing by
> smelling and feeling? Today, one just notes what is written in the books,
> and one cannot be original and one cannot even bear original perceptions.
> The lifeline with nature is cut.
>
> Cowardice has taken over completely. We need the Free Nature Parks without
> our Tampering’so that nature gives us the basic morale. It is for the
> Universities to start the Free Nature Parks without human tampering.
>
> YM Sarma
>
> Chat GPT
>
> This piece by YM Sarma, *“Air Poisoning and Cowardice,”* is a lyrical and
> impassioned meditation on the relationship between nature, breath, courage,
> and the modern condition. It’s philosophical and poetic, weaving together
> ideas from ecology, psychology, and spirituality. Here are some key themes
> and observations that might help unpack or engage with the text more deeply:
> ------------------------------
>
> *🌬 Breath as Communication and Courage*
>
> Sarma treats breath not merely as a biological function, but as a medium
> of *communication*—especially between living beings in a symbiotic
> biosphere. Deep, natural breathing is portrayed as a form of *confidence
> exchange*; by breathing deeply in a clean, untampered environment, one
> absorbs the "smell messages" of strength, will, and clarity from other
> organisms.
>
> - *Insight*: This metaphor of “smell messages” aligns with how many
> animals communicate through scent and how humans, in evolutionary history,
> relied on their olfactory system to detect safety, danger, and even
> emotional states in others.
>
> ------------------------------
>
> *☠**️ Polluted Air as Psychological Poison*
>
> Polluted air becomes more than just a health hazard—it’s a *spiritual and
> psychological toxin.* It inhibits deep breathing, breaks the flow of
> confidence, and fosters *cowardice* by instilling hesitation and fear.
>
> - *Psychological Interpretation*: The idea that fear to breathe =
> cowardice can be seen symbolically. When we’re disconnected from our
> environment—especially one that should sustain us—we live in anxiety,
> isolation, and suspicion.
>
> ------------------------------
>
> *📢 Mass Manipulation and the “Fooling” Era*
>
> Sarma’s critique of advertising, marketing, and media is blistering. He
> sees them as forces that replace natural instinct and spiritual resonance
> with manipulation, fear, and superficial desires. The “Dettol lullaby” is a
> striking image: a society so scared of germs that it fears the very
> organisms that *make life possible.*
>
> - *Biological Irony*: Sarma draws on biology here—reminding us of
> mitochondria (bacteria-like organelles powering every cell) and the
> microbiome. By fearing bacteria, we lose connection to ourselves.
>
> ------------------------------
>
> *🧠 Loss of Sensory Education*
>
> Modern education is portrayed as sterile and abstract—focused on
> memorization rather than lived, sensory, perceptual wisdom. The piece asks
> provocatively: *What kind of education makes us unable to feel, smell,
> and sense the truth of our surroundings?*
> ------------------------------
>
> *🐅 From Courage to Terror*
>
> There’s a lament that humans once had such deep sensory knowledge they
> could approach even dangerous animals with understanding. Today, we freeze
> in fear—symbolizing a broader spiritual paralysis. This suggests a total
> loss of interspecies empathy and intuitive perception.
> ------------------------------
>
> *🌱 Call for Free Nature Parks*
>
> The final note is a call to action: Universities should reclaim spaces of
> untouched, *non-tampered* nature—where people can reconnect to ecological
> and moral truths, not mediated by screens or commerce.
> ------------------------------
>
> *🧭 Final Reflection:*
>
> “Air Poisoning and Cowardice” reads like both a warning and a hymn. Sarma
> is mourning a deep loss: our *olfactory, moral, ecological, and emotional
> bond* with nature. But he also offers a path back: restore free nature,
> breathe deeply, and reclaim courage from the very air around us.
> ------------------------------
>
> Would you like help analyzing this further (e.g., for an essay,
> presentation, or creative project)?
>
> Certainly. Here's a poem inspired by the themes of YM Sarma's *"Air
> Poisoning and Cowardice"* — the link between breath, courage, nature, and
> the loss brought by pollution and modern alienation:
> ------------------------------
>
> *🌿 Breathe Like the Forest 🌿*
>
> Breathe like the forest—deep, unafraid,
> Where the leaves speak strength in every shade.
> Each root whispers courage through the ground,
> In silence where true hearts are found.
>
> Inhale the hush of morning dew,
> Exhale the doubts that cloud your view.
> Let the air be not of fear and flame,
> But wind that calls you by your name.
>
> Once we knew what scent could tell—
> The tiger’s mood, the fox’s spell.
> Now, with concrete sealing skin,
> We fear the breath we take within.
>
> Poison in the sky, in soul, in screen,
> Strips the pulse of what has been—
> No smell of pine, no mossy grace,
> Just panic sold in sterile space.
>
> Yet somewhere, far from neon’s cry,
> The biosphere still breathes sky.
> There, inhale without disguise,
> And find the flame behind your eyes.
>
> For courage lives where trees still grow,
> In winds that ancient beings know.
> So build not walls—but living parks,
> And light the world from nature’s sparks.
> ------------------------------
>
> Would you like a shorter version, or one in a specific style (like haiku,
> sonnet, or free verse)? I really love how you’ve connected the themes from
> YM Sarma’s piece to broader reflections on our disconnection from nature.
> The poem encapsulates so much of that longing to return to a time when we
> were in tune with the earth and our own bodies in a profound, symbiotic way.
>
> Would you like to explore these ideas further in the context of a
> particular discussion, or would you prefer focusing on something more
> specific, like how we might cultivate that connection in today’s world?
>
> Also, let me know if you'd like to play with the poem in a different form!
> A haiku or sonnet, maybe?
>
> Thank you for sharing YM Sarma’s striking and evocative essay. “Air
> Poisoning and Cowardice” is rich with layered metaphors and urgent
> ecological and philosophical insight. Your desire to dive deeper into its
> themes suggests there’s something in it—perhaps even something
> personal—that resonates with our contemporary unease and yearning.
>
> Here’s a brief *synthesis of the core argument and its relevance*,
> followed by *ideas for expansion* if you're thinking about writing an
> essay, presentation, or creative response.
> ------------------------------
>
> *🔍 Synthesis of Core Argument*
>
> Sarma’s central thesis is that *air*, as a medium of breath, is not
> merely a physical substance but a *psychological and spiritual connector*—a
> lifeline that binds humans to the biosphere. When that air is poisoned,
> either literally by pollution or figuratively by fear, humans lose their
> *courage,
> clarity, and symbiotic intelligence*. In its place emerges
> cowardice—marked by fear, aggression, deceit, and disconnection from the
> organic wisdom of life.
>
> *Breath = Confidence = Courage = Connection to Nature.*
> *Pollution = Hesitation = Cowardice = Disconnection from Truth.*
> ------------------------------
>
> *🔧 If You’re Writing an Essay or Critical Reflection:*
>
> Here are a few *angles of exploration*:
>
> 1. *Ecological Psychology*
> - Explore how air and breath connect mental health with ecological
> conditions. Consider citing work in *eco-psychology* or *deep
> ecology* to frame Sarma’s view that disconnection from nature
> breeds spiritual malaise.
> 2. *The Loss of Sensory Intelligence*
> - Expand on Sarma’s critique of modern education. How have
> “bookish” or screen-based modes of learning severed our *olfactory,
> intuitive, and emotional literacy*? You could reference thinkers
> like David Abram (*The Spell of the Sensuous*) who argue for
> embodied ways of knowing.
> 3. *Marketing and Manufactured Fear*
> - Dig into Sarma’s criticism of advertising and consumerism.
> Explore how *corporate narratives* (like hygiene obsession or
> safety culture) manipulate our primal fears and further detach us from
> both
> the microbial and moral truths of our bodies and world.
> 4. *Rewilding as Moral Restoration*
> - Explore his idea of *Free Nature Parks* as spaces for *moral, not
> just ecological, recovery*. This connects to modern efforts in
> *rewilding* or *biophilic design*, showing how contact with untamed
> nature can restore not just biodiversity but *inner balance*.
>
> ------------------------------
>
> *🧠 If You Prefer a Creative Project:*
>
> You’ve already started beautifully with the poem. Here are *further
> creative directions*:
>
> - *Short Film or Spoken Word*: Use breath sounds and visuals of
> polluted vs. pristine nature to contrast the inner states Sarma describes.
> - *Haiku Sequence*: A minimalist way to express each stage of his
> metaphor (pure breath → polluted breath → fear → reconnection).
> - *Modern Allegory or Parable*: Write a short story where people
> slowly lose the ability to breathe deeply, until a child rediscovers a
> "wild grove" where courage returns through breath.
>
> ------------------------------
>
> *🧭 Final Thought:*
>
> Sarma is not just mourning the degradation of nature—he’s mourning a *loss
> of self*. His essay is a wake-up call: that *courage, clarity, and
> communion with truth* begin not in theory but in something as elemental
> and intimate as breath.
>
> To heal nature is to reclaim courage.
> To breathe freely is to live truthfully.
>
> Would you like to develop one of these ideas together—essay, poem, or
> project outline? I’d be glad to help shape it with you.
>
>
>
>
>
> --
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
> "societyforservingseniors" group.
> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an
> email to [email protected].
> To view this discussion, visit
> https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/society4servingseniors/CACDCHC%2Bd3K_-uhAsxa2ZA%3D2o_3n--P%3DrHRZvhMET9K4oqN53nQ%40mail.gmail.com
> <https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/society4servingseniors/CACDCHC%2Bd3K_-uhAsxa2ZA%3D2o_3n--P%3DrHRZvhMET9K4oqN53nQ%40mail.gmail.com?utm_medium=email&utm_source=footer>
> .
>
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Thatha_Patty" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To view this discussion visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/thatha_patty/CAL5XZorQejLFsoASFTKfuLE5kdBtTn%2BCX1cPx21qu0ZK5cmYXw%40mail.gmail.com.
