Hi Mikael, Thanks for the comments. > I am confused by: > > "Note that the PTP LSPs MUST only carry PTP messages and MAY carry > MPLS/MPLS-TP control and management messages such as BFD and LSP- > Ping." > > If it is only allowed to carry PTP messages, how can it be allowed to > carry other traffic as well? Perhaps rephrasing is in order? > "MUST NOT > carry any traffic other than PTP messages or MPLS control and > management > messages..." ?
We do explain this in section 9 that one MAY need to carry some OAM and management messages to manage these PTP LSPs and PTP PWs. > > In section 10, I think it should be treated as control plane > traffic with > higher priority than what mostly is used for EF? Or is EF > (which might > carry a lot of voice traffic as well) enough? EF is better than the default. I don't think we can mandate AF since that would require operators to provide assurance of delivery as long as the traffic is not exceeding certain rate. Now, how does define that rate? > > In section 12-13 there is RSVP-TE and OSPF, what about ISIS? Changes are similar to IS-IS and will get into the next version. > > In 14.3, is "Non-155-aware LSRs" a typo and should be > "non-1588-aware" ? Thanks for catching this. Again, will get into the next version. Cheers, Manav _______________________________________________ TICTOC mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/tictoc
