Ciao PMario I'm going to reply to this in detail later, after thought, as it is very interesting!
Let me say one thing now that your post assumes something implicit ... that "order is good" ... doesn't really convince me, other than: "I want it". ... If 1 tiddler only > contains 2 sentences there is a high chance, that order matters. Search > will probably open them "out of order". The problem with this is it negates the idea of emerging order when you have none yet. I'm most interested in emergent pattern, less so in what is already known. Let's argue :-). Best wishes TT On Sunday, 19 January 2020 11:49:30 UTC+1, PMario wrote: > > Hmmmm, > > We "kind of know", that nobody like*d* that behaviour. > > TiddlyWikiClassic did exactly, what you described, with the search > dialogue. ... Guess what. Nobody liked it. The first thing everyone did > was, import the "SimpleSearchPlugin > <https://classic.tiddlywiki.com/#SimpleSearchPlugin>", which did open a > "match list" and a button. > > - If you download the classic wiki, > - delete the plugin, > - save and reload, > > You can test the "original" behaviour. ... It sucks. > > -------------- > > I don't see a reason, why users should wait several seconds for all > tiddlers to open. ... You could create a new search, that opens all > tiddlers, which contain the "search term". ... But this would also create > a UI freeze with each keystroke. ... > > So my minimal solution would be an "Open All" button in the search > dialogue. .. So the user has control. see TWc > > The other drawback I see, if users use "bad search terms" eg: "and" or > "the", which probably will find every tiddler. Only experienced users would > use search terms, that create a list that is small enough, that it makes > sense to open it. > > Your example: > > Imagine a large screen. Imagine your Tiddlers display small fragments (a >> sentence or two). Imagine it has columns. >> > = possible 50+ Tiddlers on screen at once. >> > > doesn't really convince me, other than: "I want it". ... If 1 tiddler only > contains 2 sentences there is a high chance, that order matters. Search > will probably open them "out of order". > > have fun! > mario > > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "TiddlyWiki" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/33abf7d6-481b-4d8f-8ccc-a46f4c6e1dc9%40googlegroups.com.
