Hi Mat, I really appreciate your time and critical review. On Saturday, January 25, 2020 at 7:41:39 PM UTC+3:30, Mat wrote: > > Mohammad, it could be just me but things seem to behave strangely: > > I downloaded the attached zip and extracted, getting two files: empty and > index. > > First trying out empty. I open it, go to ctrlpanel and select Solo > storyview (for testing purposed it would probably make more sense to have > this pre-set). Anyway, OK I close ctrlpanel so I only have GetingStarted > and now click "+" to create a new tid. It opens in edit mode along with the > already active GettingStarted. (Maybe I misunderstood the whole premise but > I was expecting it to be only one tiddler open at a time? But OK, maybe > it's not only one becaseu one is in view mode and one is in edit mode so > maybe the latter "doesn't count"...) >
I confirm this issue and I reported to Jeremy! > > After I've saved the tiddler I note that the sidebar tab is not named Open > but History. And it lists: New Tiddler, *Draft of 'New Tiddler'*, > GettingStarted. I would think that second title should not be there. > Clicking it confuses things even more. > Seems for Solo, Open tab does not have any use as there is one tiddler is open at a time. But I also confused when first I saw it! I like something similar for all story view. see https://github.com/Jermolene/TiddlyWiki5/pull/3412#issuecomment-576789925 > If I create yet another "New Tiddler 1", I get the same issue with a > missing Draft showing in the History list. > confirmed! > > If I reload the wiki and forget to set the Solo storyview but instead > first click "+" to create a new tiddler but realize my mistake so I cancel > the editview tiddler and then go to ctrlpanel and activate Solo, then upon > closing the ctrlpanel the missing Draft pops up (hm!) and clicking "+" > right away saves it as an existing tiddler but named "Draft of 'New > Tiddler'". > Confirmed! > > OK, deciding that the empty version is not quite ready for prime time I go > to "index". > > This starts up with the usual default tiddlers open. I go to ctrpanel and > note that Solo is pre-set. Closing the ctrlpanel... every tiddler > closes/disappears. Actually what happened what that when I went to > ctrlpanel, those default closed but I didn't see it because they were below > the ctrlpanel. Not sure how to ideally handle that. > > As with empty, the drafts seem to be listed in the History tab. I'd > suggest that only existing drafts are actually listed - or is there a > thought behind it? This time, clicking "+" does not seem to save it though > but instead a "New Tiddler" is opened in draft mode and the History list is > updated accordingly. (This makes me wonder if empty and index don't > actually have the same version of the machanism...) > Confirmed! The missing Draft and missing Deleted tiddler sometimes were opened in story view are really confusing! > > > Thanks for exploring cool concepts, Mohammad. > Thank you Mat. I noticed it was you started this concept in 2015 https://github.com/Jermolene/TiddlyWiki5/issues/1938#issue-106434605 > > <:-) > I will put a note on GitHub to inform Jeremy --Mohammad -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "TiddlyWiki" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/83354da4-f9a4-4aaf-8801-d08b53a69645%40googlegroups.com.
