Matabele -
Ha! I drop an off-the-cuff reference to something and next time I look
you've built something! Fantastic :-)
My main thought; Doesn't tagger (be it simple or not) deserve to be a tool
button on it's own? I'm not repeating my preiouvs point about *where* to
display it, I'm saying; why should it be hidden in the Info button? It is
"clearly" a set of features in itself and the practical use of it
overshadows the rest of the stuff under Info.
Regarding the introduced tag managing features - superb with immediate
access just when you need it. I like that a lot!
Overall I think the interface might need some simplification. Here are some
ideas;
First, and very connected to the "Info button vs separate button"; there is
the checkbox Uninstall Above. If simple tagger is stays in Info, I agree it
is desirable to be able to remove it from Above, but it still appears a bit
odd with the repeated display under the tab also. Perhaps instead options
"Above" OR "As Tab" ?
Checkbox to select color for Simple tagger. I doubt I'd personally ever use
this. And width... is there a reason to ever not have it display at max
width?
In my mockup I made a mistake and I think it is reapeated here; it is
overkill to have the tagpill in the selected color and still show the
selected color as a color. The former should be enough (right?). Or perhaps
one could merge the colored color picker with the hex color display, so
that clicking on the hex it *also *opens the color picker.
The Count. At this displayed spot it is a "post-fact" - it doesn't really
affect much ("ok, 3 other tiddlers using this tag...so?"). A Count number
would bring more value if it is exposed during the tag *selection*, i.e
when creating new tags: IMO a value in Count is (or would be) so that *similar
*or redundant tags can be exposed and eliminated. Particularly when we
TWederate, instead of seeing all of: *Image, image, Img, img, Picture,
picture, Pic, ... x2 for plural*, etc, I think it'll be valuable to have
very transparent tagging so natural "categories" will emerge. *"Ok, I'm
about to tag this tiddler... 3 other tiddlers use tag image but 33 use tag
Image".* - Does this have to do with Simple tagger... you decide ;-)
Actually -but this is probably trickier to implement - I think the cleanest
UI woudl be to have the tag settings display as a dropdown menu from
clicking the tag. Currently, clicking the tag deletes it, so this could
instead be e.g the first option in a small/slim dropdown menu. Just a
thought. If the colored color field is omitted and perhaps the Count, it
would only be a few "menu items" and it would be identical for each tag.
BTW, what does "checkbox Default Tagger/Fields" do?
Again, thank you Matabele!
<:-)
>
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"TiddlyWiki" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/tiddlywiki.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/25e1d390-a365-41fe-b5af-e4c139d7d243%40googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
