Hi Mohammad, Definitely, the one without ids is the recommended one. I just left the one with id there in case say, somebody copies an entire article from a website and want to build a mini table of contents for that article without having to go through the pain of converting all ids.
As for supporting it, I was thinking another modification. Currently in TW5 there is support for a pre-navigation hook - for something to happen just before navigation to start. However if we can have a post navigation hook, this method can be implemented in a more native TW5 way, as pointed out by PMario. On Saturday, 28 September 2019 02:02:10 UTC+5:30, Mohammad wrote: > > Hi Riz, > > Thank you for your efforts. > > I like the one with no id as it is more Tiddlywiki friendly! > > I hope you discuss this with Jeremy and hopefully it can be supported! > > --Mohammad > > On Thursday, September 26, 2019 at 7:16:40 PM UTC+3:30, Riz wrote: >> >> Hello Community, >> >> You know at least rarely we have that long tiddler and wish there was a >> way to navigate to parts of tiddler same way you navigate to different >> tiddlers. Well say no more. >> >> *How to see it is working?* >> 1. Download the 2 JSONs attached >> 2. Download TWO empty wikis. Drag and drop "working-example-with-id" to >> emptywiki-1 and "working-example-without-id-reccommended" to emptywiki-2 >> 3. Refresh both wikis :IMPORTANT: >> 4. Open the tiddler named "One" >> 5. Click on the links and see if it is moving you correctly to intended >> targets. >> 6. Now close tiddler name "One" :IMPORTANT: >> 7. Open tiddler named "Two" >> 8. Click on the link and see if you are correctly navigated to third >> heading in tiddler named "One" >> 9. Repeat the process in emptywiki-2 >> >> >> *working-example-with-id: How to use it?* >> Remember one thing. You should not use it. Coda has very well explained >> why TW community should not use it in here >> <https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/tiddlywikidev/C2JWmchpyaw/czI86aDvAAAJ>. >> >> >> >> *Then why are you giving us the "working-example-with-id"?* >> Well, funsies. Sometimes we have to do exactly the thing we are told not >> to. So who cares if HTML police will come after us? Live precariously and >> die while you are still handsome, am I right? >> >> *Enough. How to actually use it?* >> 1. When you are writing a long tiddler and have a part you want linked >> to, give it a UNIQUE "id". For eg: >> <div id="ultimateIDtheSecond"> Whatcha lookin' at</div> >> or >> <h2 id="pleasePassMeSomeCurry">Horrified Rabbit</h2> >> >> >> 2. Now you can link it like this >> <$link to="mytiddler" scroll="no" anchor="ultimateIDtheSecond">Link to >> ultimateIDtheSecond</$link> >> <$link to="myOthertiddler" scroll="no" >> anchor="pleasePassMeSomeCurry">Link to pleasePassMeSomeCurry</$link> >> >> >> >> 3. Note a few important things: >> - As you must have guessed, anchor part is where you give the id to >> link to. >> - scroll="no" is a must. Why is it a must? Well if scroll is set to >> yes(which it is by default), TW5 will try to scroll to the title of the >> tiddler. >> - You can link to the ID from any tiddler, anywhere (Sure, within the >> same wiki. This is not magic, after all) >> - If you are linking to IDs in the same tiddler, you may drop the "to" >> part. >> <$link scroll="no" anchor="ultimateIDtheSecond">Link to >> ultimateIDtheSecond</$link> >> - If you are too lazy to write 'scroll="no"', you may drop it. However >> you will have to press down Control when you click. >> >> *Then how to use working-example-without-id-reccommended* >> Well, the same. Except this time, you have to write "data-id" instead of >> "id" inside the html tags. So it will be like >> <span data-id="tiddloidIsAwesomeGuys">I will admit to nothing</span> >> <article data-id="oneLastTimeSomebodyPassMeTheCurry">Have you thought >> about how we might be the last few generations of humans to ever exist? >> </article> >> >> Links widget should be used to same way as above. Eg: >> <$link to="mytiddler" scroll="no" anchor="tiddloidIsAwesomeGuys">Link to >> tiddloidIsAwesomeGuys</$link> >> >> >> >> *What happens if two elements have same data-id or we transclude tiddlers >> and thus data-ids got duplicated?* >> Well, browser will scroll you to whichver instance is at the top most. >> >> *But the JSON is large!* >> Well, the whole feature is under 20 lines of code. Not bad for someone >> whose primary language is not JS(pats on the back). However, those 20 lines >> appear between some big core tiddlers. So you know how these things are. >> The code is here. If anybody want it as a part of core, they have all the >> necessary permissions to create a PR. >> PS: I swear I could have done it under 15 but VS-Code said it has to look >> pretty:/ >> >> *Can we use both JSONs in same wiki?* >> No. Although if you want links targetting both ids, data-ids or you want >> to link to things in a more generalised way - say link to a *div with >> class "whiteGlobularCap"* or something, it will only require very slight >> modifications. >> >> *There are some edge cases here. What to do?* >> I am not promising any support. However if you post it, I might be >> atleast curious to see what happened? >> >> *Credits* >> PMario figured out a rather important piece of puzzle here >> <https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/tiddlywikidev/NcCXnZu-OJE> >> >> *Are you batman? * >> I will neither confirm nor deny that. Only nobody has seen batman and me >> in the same room. >> >> Sincerely, >> Riz >> >> Solving big things in small ways. >> > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "TiddlyWiki" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/d8a6948b-f89f-480a-9609-ed31bea81daa%40googlegroups.com.
