[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
> In defense of America, we should note that the kid got it right.
>
>   
They specially pick the kids for that.
She's right, you know, they do speak French in (parts of) Europe. :-(

Canada's not much better, actually. When I was just finishing my PhD, I 
was teaching history of psychology at one of the top schools in Canada 
(U. Toronto, so you would expect to get pretty good students, on 
average). It was early in the course, I was lecturing about Ancient 
Greece and its wars with Persia (which then extended all the way through 
present-day Turkey).  I had intended all this as a little bit of 
background for the "important" (i.e., psychological) material, vaguely 
assuming they had all taken a Plato-to-NATO course in high school or 
first year university. Anyway, I could see I was losing them, so I found 
a map of the Aegean (showing the coasts of Greece and Turkey), threw it 
up on the overhead, and continued on. Still, things were a little odd.

The following week, I decided to have a "pop" quiz -- a map of modern 
Europe with all the countries' boundaries drawn in, but they had to 
supply the names. I figured it would be a little fun (more visual, less 
verbal), and most of them could show me what they knew (and the few who 
couldn't would take the hint).

Boy, was I wrong. The average number of European countries these 
students could name on the map was about  FOUR: usually England, often 
France, sometimes Spain and/or Italy. Almost never Germany. Almost never 
Greece. The bit of Turkey that stuck into the map, when it was labeled 
at all, was often called India or China (meaning virtually all of Asia 
was missing form their mental maps of the world). I was flabbergasted. 
They were irritated and grumpy. The course proceeded, but neither of us 
got completely over the incident. Being a pedagogidolt at the time (I 
like to think I'm somewhat less so now) , I did it again the next year. 
Same result. I never did that test again. I just teach them the 
geographical material now, as though they had never seen a map before 
coming to my class.


Chris
-- 

Christopher D. Green
Department of Psychology
York University
Toronto, ON M3J 1P3
Canada

 

416-736-2100 ex. 66164
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.yorku.ca/christo/



"Part of respecting another person is taking the time to criticise his 
or her views." 

   - Melissa Lane, in a /Guardian/ obituary for philosopher Peter Lipton

=================================


---
To make changes to your subscription contact:

Bill Southerly ([EMAIL PROTECTED])

Reply via email to