I received around the same number of commendations as I did criticisms of my critique of "The Nurture Assumption," but the former ALL were sent directly to me whereas the latter were ALL posted to the listserv. I found that kind of weird as it seems to imply that folks feel a bit intimidated to "go public" with their positive reactions to a critique of Harris?
Regardless, it's of little import, as I quite appreciated each and every one of you who took time out of your busy schedule to provide helpful feedback relative to which aspects were cited as being valid and important as well as segments that were cited as requiring revision. I am moving forward with this critique as certain parties have expressed interest in bringing it to a wider audience. But, never fear, I won't be sending any further installments to the TIPS listserv. For those of you who would like to receive the completed critique (and have not already expressed an interest in such), I will be more than pleased to provide such. Joan [email protected] > This has been a very time consuming project as I wish to be as thorough > and precise as possible. In the attachement I have stated what my major > concerns were and then provided precise and plentiful examples of most as > I reviewed Chapter One. That's only as far as my semi-final draft has > gone but it will give you folks a fairly good idea why I feel this book > has a number of fatal flaws. I hope the attachment is allowed. If not, > then I will need to include it in the text of an email tomorrow. > > Joan > Joan Warmbold Boggs > [email protected] > --- > To make changes to your subscription contact: > > Bill Southerly ([email protected]) --- To make changes to your subscription contact: Bill Southerly ([email protected])
