At 7:12 PM -0500 3/28/01, Serdikoff, Sherry L. wrote:
>Chuck: I'm interested in exactly what you would provide in terms of a
>"scoring matrix." Can you post the matrix for the example you provided?
Sure. Here is the question with the scoring rubric. It is formatted
much better in MS Word (see attachment). The numbers to the left are
the point you receive for the various levels of excellence in
answering that part of the expectation.
Folks will be interested to know with this question, and with giving
the scoring system away ahead of time, the average points received on
the essay was 19 (mode, 20), with a range from 7 to 24. The (F. S.
or psych) is short for Freud, Skinner, or other stuff from our intro
psych text (Mynatt & Doherty).
Sorry about this formatting (the attachment looks much more straight
forward). We actually use the sheet on the attachment to do the
scoring and attach it to the returned essay.
-Chuck
-----------------------------------------------------
2. What are Skinner and Freud's position on Free Will vs.
Determinism? Does Huff agree with them? Do you? Why?
Freud Determinism (with rational choice)
0) Not mentioned
1) Mentioned but no explanation or example
2) Explained well or clear example given
3) Explained well with additional insight (e.g. to F., S. or Psych.)
or other excellence
Freud determinism is Internal (mostly)
0) Not mentioned
1) Mentioned but no explanation or example
2) Explained well or clear example given
3) Explained well with additional insight (e.g. to F., S. or Psych.)
or other excellence
Skinner Determinism (with self control)
0) Not mentioned
1) Mentioned but no explanation or example
2) Explained well or clear example given
3) Explained well with additional insight (e.g. to F., S. or Psych.)
or other excellence
Skinner determinism is External (mostly)
0) Not mentioned
1) Mentioned but no explanation or example
2) Explained well or clear example given
3) Explained well with additional insight (e.g. to F., S. or Psych.)
or other excellence
Huff Determinism (but responsibility)
0) Not mentioned
1) Mentioned but no explanation or example
2) Explained well or clear example given
3) Explained well with additional insight (e.g. to F., S. or Psych.)
or other excellence
Huff emphasizes choice of constraints
0) Not mentioned
1) Mentioned but no explanation or example
2) Explained well or clear example given
3) Explained well with additional insight (e.g. to F., S. or Psych.)
or other excellence
Your position on Determinism? (but ?)
0) Not mentioned
1) Mentioned but no explanation or example
2) Explained well or clear example given
3) Explained well with additional insight (e.g. to F., S. or Psych.)
or other excellence
Your reasons
0) Not mentioned
1) Mentioned but no explanation or example
2) Explained well or clear example given
3) Explained well with additional insight (e.g. to F., S. or Psych.)
or other excellence
24 possible
Exam__1_Essay_Rubrics.doc
