(Following up on this a little late, but it's definitely worth
discussing).

On Wed, 17 Oct 2001 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

> Date: Wed, 17 Oct 2001 15:43:42 -0700 (PDT)
> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Subject: Re: [PATCH] Files to start implementation of an "Administrative
>     Apps" webapp  in Tomcat 4.x
>
> Given the complexity of the app and the fact that it has many external
> deps ( including JMX, etc), wouldn't be a better idea to create a separate
> repository, in the style of jakarta-tomcat-jasper and
> jakarta-tomcat-connector ?
>

Historically, the admin UI for each version of Tomcat has lived with the
sources of that version.  Because the details are so initmately dependent
on the internals of that particular server version, it makes sense to me
that we continue the convention in this case as well.


> >From that URL it seems the app will use:
> - JMX
> - Soap
> - Struts
> - RMI
> - ???
>
> While having an admin interface would be great, discussing and agreeing on
> the overal architecture would be even better - it seems a bit too heavy (
> at least for my taste ). ( "simpler is better" :-)
>

The functional specs were posted quite a long time ago and got zero
comment -- IMHO the best way to get opinions is to follow your example and
just commit some code :-).  That way, people can take a look, kick the
tires, and take a look around.

> Costin
> (BTW, why doesn't somebody propose Patrick as a commiter ? )
>

Thanks to Christopher for taking care of that little detail.

Craig

Reply via email to