From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Ingrid Sent: Friday, January 15, 2010 4:34 PM Subject: Hedy Epstein "Holocaust Survivor" downgraded to "Refugee" after criticising Zionism and their actions against Palestinians
The Forward: Row over definition of Holocaust survivor By Leon Symons, January 14, 2010 A row has broken out over the meaning of the term Holocaust survivor after an 85-year-old grandmother used it to describe herself when criticising Israeli action against Palestinians. German-born Hedy Epstein was attacked by a senior figure in the Zionist Federation who dismissed her as a refugee "touted as a trophy survivor" to help vilify Israel. The row exploded into a heated online exchange and a debate about whether historians had a proper definition of the term. Jonathan Hoffman, a vice chair of the ZF, wrote in his blog on the JC website: "Hedy Epstein is a 'refugee'. She is not a 'survivor'. To call her a 'survivor' is an insult to genuine survivors and to their families. Hedy Epstein was never in a camp, a ghetto or a death march." He agreed that Ms Epstein came to England on the kindertransport from Germany on May 18 1939 and went on: "The Yad Vashem definition of a 'survivor' is someone who was in a camp or in Germany or an occupied country after the War broke out. Epstein does not conform to that definition. "If she - and the people who are using her - are prepared to call her a 'survivor' to add weight to her mendaciousness about Israel, then it is perfectly reasonable to point out that she is not a 'survivor' but a 'refugee'. By using her status as a tool to vilify Israel, she - and those who use her - have made that status a matter of public interest." The posting attracted more than 40 comments, ranging from one calling Mr Hoffman a "Holocaust revisionist" to others saying the only reason for drawing attention to her was because she was siding with the Palestinians and that it was "all about politics". Speaking from her home in Missouri, Ms Epstein said she adopted the term only after a Holocaust museum described her as a survivor. The United States Holocaust Museum in Washington DC had also applied the term to her. "It was not something I called myself to begin with. Sometimes it's uncomfortable because it labels me and I am a lot of other things," she said. She grew up in the village of Kippenheim and was called "a dirty Jew" and thrown out of school after Hitler came to power in 1933 when she was eight. "My father was sent to Dachau before I was sent to England at 14. That was the last time I saw my parents and they and almost all my relatives were killed in camps in France and at Auschwitz." After England, she went to a surviving uncle and aunt in America. She said her stance on Israel was rooted in her parents' anti-Zionism. But she took little notice until the massacres of Palestinian refugees by Lebanese Christian militiamen in the Sabra and Shatila refugee camps in 1982. She has visited the West Bank five times and was in Egypt last week for a Gaza freedom march. She has been to Israel to visit a Holocaust memorial that bears her parents' names. She admitted: "My views have been coloured by what I have seen and lived through. I knew from early childhood what persecution and oppression was like. Some Holocaust survivors disagree with my views, others don't." And she pointed to another paragraph from Yad Vashem which stated: "One can also define Shoah survivors as Jews who lived for any amount of time under Nazi domination, direct or indirect, and survived it . . . as well as Jews who forcefully left Germany in the 1930s, after the rise of the Nazis to power. No historical definition can be completely satisfactory." WHAT THE EXPERTS SAY Experts agree on one thing: there is no single definition of who is a Holocaust survivor. Everyone agrees that it includes those who were in the camps and were caught in Nazi-occupied Europe from 1933 to 1945 But there are some who adopt a wider definition. The Claims Conference in New York, for example, cited many different classifications from the German government about who could make a claim under different programmes and was therefore a survivor. Lord Janner, chair of the Holocaust Educational Trust, was unequivocal: "If Hedy Epstein was on the kindertransport, she is a Holocaust survivor. What she is doing might be abhorrent and sad but kindertransport are survivors." Historian and Holocaust expert Professor David Cesarani said: "There is no single definition of a Holocaust survivor. It is technically more correct to describe those who came to the UK in 1938-39 as former refugees from Nazi persecution. But if they feel like survivors I don't see why they should not be allowed to think and speak of themselves as such. Both terms, 'Holocaust' and 'survivor' have become woefully imprecise." Denis MacShane MP, chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Inquiry into Antisemitism, said: "My interpretation would be someone who has been in one of the death camps or prison camps." Baroness Deech said: "My first reaction would be someone in the camps or in Europe. But this woman would never have been on the kindertransport and had to flee if not for the Nazis, so I would say she is entitled to call herself a survivor." Deborah Lipstadt, who defeated a libel action from Holocaust denier David Irving 10 years ago, agreed: "It's someone whose life was seriously disrupted by the Holocaust or had to leave Germany precipitously. However, in her case it has been milked for all it's worth." <http://www.thejc.com/forward/26071> http://www.thejc.com/print/26071 *** exposing the hidden truth for further educational research only *** CAVEAT LECTOR *** In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. NOTE: Some links may require cut and paste into your Internet Browser. Please check for daily real news posts and support the truth! (sorry but don't have time to email all posts) at <http://tinyurl.com/33c9yr> http://tinyurl.com/33c9yr or <http://groups.google.com/group/total_truth_sciences/topics?gvc=2> http://groups.google.com/group/total_truth_sciences/topics?gvc=2 ; You can also subscribe to the multiple daily emails by sending an email to <mailto:[email protected]> [email protected] ; free book download: <http://www.lulu.com/content/165077> http://www.lulu.com/content/165077 *** Revealing the hidden Truth For Educational & Further Research Purposes only. *** NOTICE: Due to Presidential Executive Orders, the National Security Agency (NSA) may have read emails without warning, warrant, or notice. They may do this without any judicial or legislative oversight. You have no recourse, nor protection.......... IF anyone other than the addressee of this e-mail is reading it, you are in violation of the 1st & 4th Amendments to the Constitution of the United States. Patriot Act 5 & H.R. 1955 Disclaimer Notice: This post & all my past & future posts represent parody & satire & are all intended for entertainment and amusement only. To be removed from the weekly list, please reply with the subject line "REMOVE"
-- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "total_truth_sciences" group. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/total_truth_sciences
