I have tried Soundcheck's script and it does work, it does improve the
sound. But its only part of a whole environment designed to get the
best out of the device.

Important things are to run external server, over a wire, and only send
PCM (no flac decoding on the Touch). Thats the starting point. THEN
these changes can be applied. Its just doing things like turning off
the wifi module, turning off samba and rearranging some process
priorities. Nothing drastic or really bizarre.

I haven't tried each piece by itself so I can't say which one of these
makes the most difference etc. So don't ask.

On my tests I found the results from these about the same as unplugging
the display. The combination of these changes, unplugging the display
and bypassing the output caps was a real home run. The results were
stunning.

I don't know exactly why these changes effect sound. I tried measuring
jitter, but the jitter on the Touch is already so low my measurement
system couldn't detect it. That does not mean these do not effect the
jitter, it DOES mean I can't afford the right test equipment!

The suggestion that all you have to do is run ADM to tell you if there
is any change is only valid if the AD converter you are using is
significantly better than the Touch itself. From my tests I do know the
Touch has significantly less than 50ps jitter. You are going to have to
look far and wide to find an AD converter that has say 5ps of jitter so
you can make meaningful measurements with ADM. You simply cannot make
meaningful jitter measurements of a device with 30ps of jitter with
test equipment that has 100ps. The results are completely meaningless.


ADM is perfectly fine for detecting things like frequency response
differences etc. But if you are making a hypothesis that some code
change is somehow causing a change in jitter, and you want to use ADM
to see if there is a change in the analog outs, the AD converter used
HAS to have significantly lower jitter than the device under test. 

Personally I CAN hear these differences. Its hard to do quick back and
forth tests because it takes a minute or two to apply or remove the
changes. I have not been able to do blind tests under these
circumstances. 

There is an interesting side note though. With these changes and the
display unplugged the sound is so good that individual changes become
far more obvious. For example streaming flac or PCM is very obvious
when these are applied and the display is unplugged. With the stock
touch it was obvious over the headphone jack, but much less obvious
over the analog out. With these changes and the unplugged display its
also quite obvious over the analog outs. 

I have not done extensive listening with the digital out. Its far more
difficult to make general statements because there is such a great
range of variation in external DACs. On one of my DACs I can't hear a
difference, on another I can maybe tell but its tough. Remember that I
build my own DACs and go to great lengths to make them as immune to
input circumstances as possible, so my experience may be different than
others with different DACs.

Summary, I can hear a difference with these changes. Whether you can or
not is of course up to you and your system. If you don't meet the basic
requirements don't even try them. (external server, wired ethernet,
streaming PCM)

If you don't like the change or you don't hear a change you can ALWAYS
reverse it so there is no risk in trying them out.

John S.


-- 
JohnSwenson
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JohnSwenson's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=5974
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=79857

_______________________________________________
Touch mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/touch

Reply via email to