On Mon, Aug 26, 2024 at 3:01 PM enh <e...@google.com> wrote:
>
> On Mon, Aug 26, 2024 at 11:14 AM T.J. Mercier <tjmerc...@google.com> wrote:
> >
> > On Fri, Aug 23, 2024 at 3:52 PM enh <e...@google.com> wrote:
> > >
> > > This dependency keeps getting hairier and hairier (json!) and the
> > > current system for policy scheduling is actually quite different from
> > > the original anyway.
> > > ---
> > > lib/portability.h | 14 --------------
> > > toys/posix/ps.c | 33 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-----
> > > 2 files changed, 28 insertions(+), 19 deletions(-)
> >
> > Hi,
> >
> > I assume this mailing list is supposed to be Content-Type: text/plain?
>
> (i don't think anybody cares that much.)
>
> > > + else if (!strcmp(s, "system-background")) strcpy(tb->pcy, "
> > > ");
> >
> > Is this empty for compatibility with the existing output?
>
> correct. i kind of hate that there's a field that _deliberately_ isn't
> parseable, but if our current argument is "we shouldn't just _remove_
> this because someone's probably using it for something", it makes
> sense to have the same output.
>
> > system_server is a "fun" case but I think this new toybox code should
> > still report the same info. It has threads in different cgroups (all
> > under the same pid of course):
> > husky:/dev/cpuset/system-background # cat cgroup.procs | xargs ps -o
> > pid,pcy,comm,cmd
> > PID PCY COMM CMD
> > 492 logd logd
> > 493 lmkd lmkd
> > 503 hwservicemanager hwservicemanage
> > 504 vndservicemanager vndservicemanag
> > 574 android.hardware.composer.+ binder:574_3
> > 727 tombstoned tombstoned
> > 976 android.hardware.sensors-s+ binder:976_3
> > 985 fg app_process64 system_server
> > 1475 storaged storaged
> > 1483 dmd dmd
> > 1581 gatekeeperd gatekeeperd
> > 1637 logcat logcat
> >
> > husky:/dev/cpuset/system-background # cat /proc/985/cgroup
> > 3:cpuset:/foreground
> > 2:cpu:/
> > 1:blkio:/
> > 0::/uid_1000/pid_985
> >
> > husky:/ # grep cpuset /proc/`pidof system_server`/task/*/cgroup
> > /proc/985/task/1028/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1029/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1031/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1032/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1033/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1034/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1035/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1036/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1037/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1038/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1049/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1050/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1051/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1052/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1053/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1054/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1055/cgroup:3:cpuset:/top-app
> > /proc/985/task/1056/cgroup:3:cpuset:/top-app
> > /proc/985/task/1057/cgroup:3:cpuset:/top-app
> > /proc/985/task/1058/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1074/cgroup:3:cpuset:/system-background
> > /proc/985/task/1075/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1083/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1084/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1089/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1090/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1092/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1094/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1095/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1096/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1097/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1101/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1104/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1106/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1107/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1108/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1109/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1110/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1111/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1112/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1113/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1114/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1115/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1117/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1124/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1126/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1127/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1131/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1615/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1617/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1621/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1659/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1660/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1661/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1662/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1663/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1664/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1665/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1668/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1669/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1672/cgroup:3:cpuset:/system-background
> > /proc/985/task/1673/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1674/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1675/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1676/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1677/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1678/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1854/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1855/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1859/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1860/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1871/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1872/cgroup:3:cpuset:/top-app
> > /proc/985/task/1873/cgroup:3:cpuset:/top-app
> > /proc/985/task/1883/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1886/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1887/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1888/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1889/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1890/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1897/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1898/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1900/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1905/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1906/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1911/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1913/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1922/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1930/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1933/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1941/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1959/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1964/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1966/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1967/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1968/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1969/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1971/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1972/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1978/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1979/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1980/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1981/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1984/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1985/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1986/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1989/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1990/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1991/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1992/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1993/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1994/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1997/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/1998/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2000/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2001/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2002/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2003/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2005/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2006/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2007/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2010/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2011/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2012/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2013/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2014/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2015/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2018/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2019/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2020/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2021/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2024/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2025/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2026/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2028/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2029/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2030/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2031/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2033/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2038/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2039/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2041/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2042/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2045/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2046/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2047/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2048/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2050/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2051/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2052/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2053/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2054/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2056/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2060/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2062/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2066/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2069/cgroup:3:cpuset:/system-background
> > /proc/985/task/2075/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2076/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2077/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2078/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2082/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2086/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2089/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2113/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2126/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2127/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2173/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2183/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2211/cgroup:3:cpuset:/system-background
> > /proc/985/task/2232/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2247/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2248/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2414/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2417/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2419/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2421/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2422/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2423/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2425/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2426/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2428/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2471/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2527/cgroup:3:cpuset:/top-app
> > /proc/985/task/2563/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2565/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2567/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2568/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2569/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2571/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2799/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2856/cgroup:3:cpuset:/top-app
> > /proc/985/task/2860/cgroup:3:cpuset:/top-app
> > /proc/985/task/2864/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2865/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2882/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2883/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2884/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2885/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2886/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2887/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2888/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2889/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2890/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2905/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/2989/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3013/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3018/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3020/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3022/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3063/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3071/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3112/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3113/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3116/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3200/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3220/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3223/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3224/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3225/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3226/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3229/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3230/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3280/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3293/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3294/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3649/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3708/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3737/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3835/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3836/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3840/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/3841/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/4828/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/4838/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/4977/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/5188/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/5765/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/5988/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/5998/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/7793/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/7995/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> > /proc/985/task/985/cgroup:3:cpuset:/foreground
> >
> >
> > > + if ((s = strstr(line, ":cpuset:/"))) {
> >
> > So this ignores the old schedtune case from get_sched_policy, however
> > I think that's ok because schedtune is an out of tree driver only in
> > Android 4.19 kernels which are EOL in 4 months at the end of this
> > December.
>
> (i have no idea what any of this means. i didn't do anything about
> "schedtune" because you didn't tell me anything about "schedtune" :-)
> )
Don't do anything about schedtune. :)
> > > + else if (!strcmp(s, "foreground-window")) strcpy(tb->pcy,
> > > "wi");
> >
> > I think this should be "foreground_window". Underscore instead of
> > hyphen for that one. Maybe we should fix that one on our side since
> > it's unlike all the others, and not actually in use yet.
>
> oops, yeah. i should have copy & pasted rather than just having the
> other code open in another window.
>
> new patch attached.
>
> > > else strcpy(tb->pcy, "?");
> >
> > Should this be two ?s to maintain the column width?
>
> there's a %2s where these actually come out. my only concern was that
> the "-" ("missing") case was distinct from the "?" ("unknown") case.
Ah right.
> > This solution will work as long as Android continues to use cpuset v1.
> > A v2 upgrade should happen at some point, but it's not clear when.
> > New policy names and abbreviations will have to be manually synced
> > with this if any are added (which should be rare):
> > https://cs.android.com/android/platform/superproject/main/+/main:system/core/rootdir/init.rc;l=360?q=mkdir.*%2Fdev%2Fcpuset
>
> long term i think we should try to work out how to get away from the
> two-letter nonsense. but that's a problem for another year. right now
> i just want to get away from these dependencies without regression
> (which should make rob happy too, since he always wants to build with
> the NDK rather than as part of the OS).
Ok, SGTM. This looks good, except I think you resent patch 0001.
_______________________________________________
Toybox mailing list
Toybox@lists.landley.net
http://lists.landley.net/listinfo.cgi/toybox-landley.net
