Hi Sage, You see what I�m talking about: for you, the camera is important, and so that�s an area of focus (pardon the pun) for you that is a minor thing for me, since I am focused on the PDA/Phone functions of the phone. Everyone has his/her own priorities. You might look at a camera image and think it�s terrible, and I might look at the same camera image and think it�s OK.
As for changes over time, while I�d prefer that PalmOne get everything right from the outset, I�d rather have them put improved cameras in later model Treo 600s than stick with an inferior camera just because that was the initial decision. Kinda like I expect the 2004 model of the Volvo XC90 to have improvements over my 2003 model. Do I like the deficiencies in my 2003? NO! But do I complain that they fixed things in the subsequent models of the same car? No. I think it�s clear that PalmOne needs to do a better job of: 1. Providing tech support that knows anything. 2. Conducting beta testing to shake out more bugs before release. 3. Providing a mechanism to get user feedback into their improvement processes quickly to allow them to honestly and quickly resolve inevitable problems in a device this complex. 4. Providing financial relief for customers who, like you, need the device to do something well which PalmOne says it can do, but doesn�t do very well. Cheers, Don ________________________________________ From: [email protected] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Sage Sokol-Lanting Sent: Wednesday, May 04, 2005 7:52 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Treo] Treo Lawsuit-- Buzzing-- May Have Merit! Care to explain how two models, exactly the same except for serial number, can have 2 different cameras? As I said, I had a t600 camera which focused in low-light as well as any camera phone, sans blue spots. Of course palmone un-technical support had no clue what i was talking about, and could tell me nothing nor do nothing about my problem. If i could, i WOULD return it, because i would just purchase a t650 with my 500$ i initially paid for a t600. I use minimal apps, so the memory issue isnt a problem, and properly functioning camera would be nice, because i take snapshots with the t600 regularly..or i did, when it had the functioning camera. Now it might as well not have the camera again. -sage � ----- Original Message ----- � From: Craig Froehle � To: [email protected] � Sent: Wednesday, May 04, 2005 4:04 AM � Subject: Re: [Treo] Treo Lawsuit-- Buzzing-- May Have Merit! � Sage, � Try taking a picture in candle-light or in twilight -- you will not � get good results. � The camera on the Treo 600 is not very good -- usable most of the � time, but not good. � Our point was that the quality of various features isn't binary -- � works or doesn't work -- but a continuum from utter crap to marvelous. � The camera is on the low end of that spectrum and most people knew � this when they bought the phone.� If you don't like the camera, you � should have returned the Treo...simple as that. � On 5/3/05, Sage Sokol-Lanting <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: � > You both mention not having issues with the t600 camera, and that it was a given it was bad. Thing is, I managed to get a t600 with a GOOD camera, which actually focused and didnt have a lot of blue fuzz. Maybe the one i got was one in 1000, but how can you justify selling a product that one in 1000 works PROPERLY! Is that not rediculous? � > -sage � >�� ----- Original Message ----- � >�� From: Don Ferguson � >�� To: [email protected] � >�� Sent: Monday, May 02, 2005 2:56 PM � >�� Subject: RE: [Treo] Treo Lawsuit-- Buzzing-- May Have Merit! � > � >�� Most people's experience of the Treo 600 is vastly different from yours.� I � >�� don't know anyone who was/is particularly happy with the Treo 600's camera. � >�� It's a compromise, since the thing is a PDA and phone first; camera second. � >�� The bluish cast and fuzziness are well understood "features" of the T600's � >�� camera.� While the 650's camera isn't higher resolution, those problems are � >�� fixed. � > � >�� I'm no fan of PalmOne's tech support these days, but I don't think you � >�� condemn a company or a smart phone because its camera is substandard. � > � >�� Cheers, � > � >�� Don � > � >���� _____ � > � >�� From: [email protected] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Sage � >�� Sokol-Lanting � >�� Sent: Monday, May 02, 2005 12:24 PM � >�� To: [email protected] � >�� Subject: Re: [Treo] Treo Lawsuit-- Buzzing-- May Have Merit! � > � >�� LOL....palmone's support is laughable. I paid 500$ worth of my hard earned � >�� money for a t600 last july, and have since had 8 (yeah, EIGHT) shoddy � >�� replacements. I want a refund, so I can spend my money on a t650 which fixes � >�� most of the problems which I had (for god sakes, the company shouldnt � >�� prototype the product on the poor customers) problem� is I dont have a � >�� choice in the matter, they just get to keep sending me shXtty replacements. � >�� my 5th or so replacement had a good camera, which means it functioned as a � >�� camera should, and would focus. 3 attempted replacements later, i gave up � >�� and kept one with a shitty camera. if they even gave me a HALF refund, 250$, � >�� i would be satisfied. At this point, I cant even get that much for my � >�� tmobile600 on ebay. Or even a customer loyalty discount for trading in a � >�� t600 for a t650, since the t600 was such a POS. Im fed up, as i've never had � >�� this broad a scope and numerous problems with a tech product before. � >�� -sage � >���� ----- Original Message ----- � >���� From: Craig Froehle � >���� To: [email protected] � >���� Sent: Monday, May 02, 2005 7:21 AM � >���� Subject: Re: [Treo] Treo Lawsuit-- Buzzing-- May Have Merit! � > � >���� So your car's water pump breaks at 40K miles and is replaced under � >���� warranty.� That new part has a 12-month, 12K mile warranty, but it, � >���� too, fails after 20K miles.� Do you really think the car company � >���� should give you your money back after you've used the car for 60K � >���� miles? � > � >���� Same for the PDA -- you used it beyond the warranty period, so the � >���� company doesn't technically owe you anything more for free since you � >���� bought the device knowing what the warranty is. � > � >���� *Should* the company try to make everyone happy?� Not really, since it � >���� can't possibly do that, and would go bankrupt trying to do so, so it � >���� has to draw the line somewhere.� That "line" is the warranty. � > � >���� If you, or others, feel that this isn't the level of customer support � >���� you deserve, then vote with your feet and buy another company's � >���� products -- there are several out there selling smartphones. � >���� Unfortunately, PalmOne knows it's the only game in town right now for � >���� Palm OS smartphones, so its motivation to placate users isn't as high � >���� as if it had some competition. � > � >���� It sucks to have something fail on you and be treated in a way you � >���� feel is unfair -- I completely sympathize with your situation (I've � >���� been there myself many times before). The most effective strategy is � >���� *always* to make your point buy not buying from them again.� Suing � >���� them only takes even *more* of their resources away from customer � >���� service (making the situation worse) while not really giving much back � >���� to the customers (the lawyers generally keep most of the settlement) � >���� and it risks putting the company out of business (which reduces � >���� competition and generally makes the whole industry worse off for firms � >���� and customers).� Lawsuits are not the answer...period. � > � >���� On 5/2/05, Jim McGowan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: � >���� > But its a wallet thing for the company too....you put out shoddy � >���� > merchandise, sell to unsuspecting innocent customers at a very nice � >�� price � >���� > and then not have to deal with the fact you sent out shoddy stuff in the � >���� > first place!??� If not a lawsuit how about a full refund instead of a � >���� > replacement - that would be fair. � >���� > JmcGowan � >���� > � >���� > At 08:32 AM 5/2/2005, you wrote: � >���� > � >���� > >Providing sub-standard customer service for a device that is out of � >���� > >warranty should certainly merit a customer no longer giving that firm � >���� > >his business (if customer service is important to him), but suing the � >���� > >company over it is just stupid.� If that isn't "frivolous," I don't � >���� > >know what is. � >���� > > � >���� > >If you don't like a company's way of doing business and it's not � >���� > >illegal, vote with your wallet -- if enough people think like you do, � >���� > >that company will be forced to improve or face extinction.� That is � >���� > >the true way capitalism works, not through stupid lawsuits. � >���� > > � >���� > > � >���� > > � >���� > >On 4/29/05, Kevin M. Maloney <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: � >���� > > > My recent experience with PalmOne makes me believe that a lawsuit is � >���� > > > warranted.� Not because of a product defect, but rather, because � >�� they are � >���� > > > not being honest with customers. � >���� > > > I had a 600 replaced under warranty because of buzzing.� The � >�� replacement � >���� > > > worked fine for about 6 months, and then started buzzing.� It was � >�� out of � >���� > > > warranty by that time, but I called PalmOne and explained the � >�� problem. I � >���� > > > tried very hard to convince them to fix the problem, but they � >�� insisted that � >���� > > > my only option was to pay them $179 for a refurbished unit that I � >�� could � >���� > > swap � >���� > > > with my buzzing unit.� I even argued that you can find 600s on ebay � >�� for � >���� > > less � >���� > > > than that, but they wouldn't change the price. � >���� > > > � >���� > > > There was no way that I was going to pay PalmOne for another 600 � >�� that would � >���� > > > likely have the same problem, so I hunted down the cigarette wrapper � >�� fix � >���� > > > procedure and tried it out.� It worked!� For the price of a stale � >�� pack of � >���� > > > cigarettes and a special screwdriver ($8), my buzzing problems were � >�� fixed. � >���� > > > I was, though, and remain, furious that Palm One hasn't at least � >�� suggested � >���� > > > to non-warranty customers this fix.� Instead, they demand $179 for a � >���� > > > replacement unit that likely has the same design defect.� Is that an � >�� honest � >���� > > > and ethical business practice? � >���� > > > � >���� > > > Sincerely, � >���� > > > � >���� > > > Kevin M. Maloney � >���� > > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] � >���� > > > � >���� > > > farhanmemon_2000 wrote: � >���� > > > > The Law Offices of Stan S. Mallison in Lafayette, California, is � >���� > > > � >���� > > > The scum offices of.... :P � >���� > > > � >���� > > > Come ON! Class Action Suits should be for things that cause pain and � >���� > > > suffering, � >���� > > > loss of work and money and stuff like that. Not a bug here and there � >�� in a � >���� > > > freaking techno-nerd gadget. � >���� > > > � >���� > > > I'm sorry, but that's frivolous, and is just another example of why � >�� this � >���� > > > country � >���� > > > is going to hell in a handbasket. � >���� > > > � >���� > > > What next? Sue palmOne for making the Treo 650 but not include WiFi? � >���� > > > � >���� > > > FEH! I say! FEH! � >���� > > > � >���� > > > -Greg � >���� > > > Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/treo/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
