Dave, I must agree with Craig.  I've owned practically every Palm device
made (with a few notable exceptions: still waiting for Lifedrive stuff to be
built into a Treo!!) and spent many months using several flavors if
WinCE/PPC.  I have a relative who works for Microsoft and saw Windows Mobile
on the new Motorola rotating phone/pda before it came out, and have played
with Windows Mobile on the Treo 700.  While I've only played with WinMob5
for a few minutes, I was able to confirm the continued presence of the
tragic flaw that is my only really big problem with OS.  Like the PalmOS's
continuing limitation of only 15 categories and only one category per item,
it has persisted since the beginning of the OS, from Windows CE, through the
various flavors of Pocket PC, and into Windows Mobile.  Unlike the tragic
flaws in PalmOS, there is no convenient way - or, really, any way at all -
to work around Windows Mobile's problem, which I've highlighted a few times.
I have not verified, but have no reason to believe otherwise, that the other
primary complaint about Windows Mobile - the method of multitasking wherein
applications don't really close until you go to the application list and
close them manually from there - persists as well.  I'd like someone to
confirm this, since operationally it results in inconvenient "out of memory"
problems which have to be cleared through a tedious manual process.  PalmOS
sidesteps this issue by largely avoiding multitasking, and there have been
much-criticized problems with PalmOS to the limited extent that it does do
multitasking.  Again, however, utilities (rlock et al) have quickly been
possible to address this problem in PalmOS.  

 

Not slamming Microsoft, or Windows Mobile, any more than I've criticized
PalmOS over the years for deficiencies they've been too slow to address, but
just because, IMHO, PalmOS is a superior USER experience to Windows Mobile -
superior, still, in terms of efficiency of the user interface - and just
because my reactions to the new Windows Mobile on the Treo can happen
quickly and without much testing, verifying the presence or absence of
long-known serious flaws in the OS, doesn't mean it's a knee jerk reaction.
It is, as is the case with many on this list, the result of many years
calendar time and thousands of hours of wall-clock time messing with and
caring about these things and the impact - positive and negative - they can
have on people's lives.

 

It's OK to judge and criticize hardware and software.  Don't be too quick to
judge or criticize people.

 

Cheers,

Don

  _____  

From: [email protected] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Craig
Froehle
Sent: Tuesday, February 28, 2006 7:22 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [SPAM]Re: [Treo] Palm vs WinMob

 

On 2/28/06, Dave Will <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Just a correction. I didn't go off on people for dissing WindowsMobile.
> I went off on people for not having objective opinions.
> I like opinions of all flavors if they are well thought through.

and

> I wonder how many of you that despise WinMob so much have
> actually used it for any period of time? ...
> Having said that, I've had this 700w for a several weeks now and
> I can sufficiently say that I know it well. I

Many of us, in fact many of us who are vocal in our preference of Palm
OS Treos, have used Windows Mobile devices in the past for far longer
than several weeks.  Just because someone might make a snide comment
or dismiss WM doesn't mean he or she is doing so based on unfounded
prejudice.  It could be (and here, often is) based on a well-informed
preference.

--



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/treo/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 


Reply via email to