Thats exaclty what I'm looking for. Some authoritative reference. I did
read about that court case about 2 years ago...


> On 3/14/07, Michael Lax <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>> Thus, copying a CD to your PC (not all of your
>> friends) is okay.  Copying that to your MP3 player is okay.
>
> Michael, IANAL, but I'm fairly sure neither of those are considered
> legal under "fair use" guidelines since the consumer is NOT merely
> making a copy, but actually transforming the content into another
> format.  While making a duplicate CD would be considered "fair use"
> (under the archival back-up provision), ripping the original CD to
> MP3/WMA would not be.  Furthermore, if the CD has any anti-duplication
> technology at all, circumventing it automatically puts the consumer at
> odds with the DMCA.
>
> Or is there an authoritative reference that provides more accurate
> interpretation of this situation?  If so, I'd love to read it! :-)
> - Craig
>


Reply via email to