I work with a lot of people ages 35-65 who use a variety of
smartphones -- about 50% WM sliders and 50% Treos.  Invariably, it is
the older people with bad eyesight (usually bi- or trifocals) who need
to bigger fonts and bigger keyboard labels to use them.  The younger
folks and those with decent eyesight all use Treos.

I've had a WM slider...couldn't stand it.  To me, a major benefit of
having a QWERTY keyboard is immediate access to lots and lots of
shortcuts (e.g., assigning them to frequently use numbers, webpages,
and applications).  If I can't do that without sliding open the
device, which is darn near impossible to do quickly and safely
one-handed, its utility greatly diminishes for me.  Besides, with the
smaller thumbboard of the Treo, one of medium-sized thumbs can cover
every letter; not so on the sliders, which _forces_ me to type
two-handed.

All in all, I'm not a fan of "big" phone keyboards unless I can
literally "type" on them -- thumbing should be done on thumb-sized
keyboards, as everything else is just a less-than-ideal compromise.
My opinion, of course.
- Craig


On 3/18/07, Don Ferguson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> The slideout keyboard is in my mind the greatest plus (roomier, fewer
> compromises needed) and the greatest minus (can't type with one thumb)
> of these devices.
>
> I'm interested in peoples' comments on this.  I use the Treo "one
> thumbed" all the time to look up contacts and appointments.
>

Reply via email to