I believe all those things you describe are currently possible on the
650, and I know they are on the 700p since I do them daily.

 

For me it's not an argument of what's under the covers - it's what the
user interacts with and what constraints the underlying OS puts on those
interactions that counts.  For example, the 15 category limit in PalmOS
has grated on me since 1996 and it's still there.  On the WinMob side,
the extremely (IMNSHO) limiting field level data input model has been
there since Windows CE version 1 (what year?) and it's still there.  

 

I have developed ways of accommodating the limitations of PalmOS such
that they don't interfere with what I need to do.  There are I'm told
ways of accommodating the limitations of Windows Mobile that help work
around those too.

 

Anyway, much like the Apple ads that try to point out flaws in Windows
that just aren't there anymore, so do many new and experienced users of
Windows Mobile try to point out deficiencies of PalmOS that aren't there
either. Things change.  PalmOS has steadily (if a bit too slowly for my
taste) improved over time without compromising the underlying simplicity
that allowed them to create this market we're discussing.

 

MacOS, Windows, Windows Mobile and PalmOS all have their flaws and
limitations.  Users have to find their own way.  Most have found their
way to Windows.  Not sure what the current stats are on PalmOS vs.
Windows Mobile market share in the US.

 

On my Treo 700p I can write an email and use the PalmOS browser (and
switch back and for the between them instantly), not miss a phone call
(except where Verizon coverage isn't so good!) and listen to music while
email, calendar and contacts are all quietly pushed in real time
(usually within a few seconds, and yes, usually before it hits my
desktop) to the device.  I do this every day.

 

I also have a choice in the area of music, for example.  I can use
Pocket Tunes and sync music with Windows Media Player.  Or, I can use
mOcean and sync with iTunes.  I'm currently figuring out which I like
better.  There are multiple browsers, voice recording programs, voice
control programs, and so on, that have features to suit different
individuals' tastes.  Or, I can just use what comes on the device and
spend my time on other things than shopping around for applications!  I
suppose this is true on Windows Mobile, too, even though it didn't used
to be.

 

All systems evolve - the trick is to keep up while still making
individual choices about what's important.

 

Fun discussion!

 

Cheers,

Don

________________________________

From: [email protected] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of
Jim Girvin
Sent: Friday, March 23, 2007 8:32 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: RE: [Treo] CNBC Exclusive: Palm Shareholder Expects Motorola
Deal Soon

 

Converted to Windows Mobile, you mean? :-)

Two words: multi tasking. I'm writing this email on m device while
listening to WM player and an IE window open. 

And I have not missed a call in a week plus my email hits my device
before my desktop.

So yea, Im converted. These are things I could never do on my Treo 650
at the same time.

My first Palm was the 105 after that the Handspring Deluxe, Palm 515 and
then the Zire 72. Finally the 650. I love Palm but I love functionality
and ability more than I love Palm.

Jim Girvin
901.486.9547 (mobile) 
901.328.5668 (fax) 
[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:jim%40memphishousehunter.com> 

*****************************************************
Sent over the air with an HTC Hermes handheld

-----Original Message-----
From: Craig Froehle <[EMAIL PROTECTED]
<mailto:craig.froehle%40gmail.com> >
Sent: Friday, March 23, 2007 9:05 AM
To: [email protected] <mailto:treo%40yahoogroups.com> 
Subject: Re: [Treo] CNBC Exclusive: Palm Shareholder Expects Motorola
Deal Soon

On 3/23/07, Jeffrey Kaplan <[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:yahoo%40gordol.org>
> wrote:
> The only way PalmOS would
> have a secure future with any company is with one that is not already
> invested in WinMob/WinSmartphone.

Nah. Palm has already shown there's wisdom in being diversified (if
not agnostic) from an OS point-of-view, so even an existing WM
licensee could produce both for a while and make future decisions
based mainly on sales. Motorola has phones running on at least two
different OS foundations: WM and Linux. So, it could be a good
owner. Impossible to tell, however, if any company would believe that
Palm OS' established user community is worth maintaining. When the
number of phones sold each year is in the Billions, several million
die-hard Palm OS fans may or may not be significant. Even people on
this list who've used Palm OS devices for years and years have shown
they're willing to at least _try_ WM or other OSes, so I am skeptical
that Palm OS can still claim as widespread a devoted userbase. Me,
I'm in until they stop making them, as I just have way too much
knowledge and expertise invested to switch to something else until I'm
forced to (and I have no significant complaints about Palm OS that are
really much better anywhere else unless I give up major functionality,
too). My 2 cents. 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Reply via email to