The OpenPC project was a failure. There were major issues that could have been resolved. The idea was to basically put out a free PC. We already had that. At least to the extent it ran free software (distribution like Trisquel). In fact it was more of a backward motion as it used OpenSuSE. OpenPC is really just a branded version of OpenSuSE with a few tweaks. It looked REALLY cool. BUT the problems were this:

1. Multiple announcements prior to the availability of the system(s). We weren't the only ones shipping an "OpenPC". It should have really been one system that had shipping from multiple continents. Then there were no announcements after it was released. It needed promotion that it never got.

2. It wasn't completely free (not from the free software perspective at least). The wording used to describe it was all wrong. "Open" is a bad word. I don't believe it actually contained non-free software as the OpenSuSE developer(s) are active in removing non-free firmware/drivers. However I think it's web site contains information on installing non-free software. That makes it a no-go in this community.

3. We already had a system with chipsets made it free software compatible (again, it's not free BIOS, X86 is never going to be 100% free even with a free BIOS) and was selling great.

4. There was an article written by someone who didn't get the facts. This was several months after the initial availability. They managed to find our web site and made up stuff for the article. Never were we contacted. They claimed for instance the US version of the OpenPC shipped with Ubuntu. It did not. Ubuntu is not free. The OpenPC version of OpenSuSE was at least not shipping non-free software for the most part (again- it isn't quite Trisquel free though). We did not ship Ubuntu with the OpenPC version which was linked from the OpenPC web site. There was an entirely different page for it. There still is. We did also ship a version with Ubuntu though. The system is still available with OpenPC. I would not recommend it. I'm doubtful the software is being maintained. It's a very old effort now and it's probably based on an unsupported version of OpenSuSE. It's not possible to find it our on web site directly.

All in all we are basically doing what the OpenPC project attempted to accomplish. A PC built for free software users. Non-free software is a hindrance to free software users and that was what the project was trying to solve. The translation / English of those running it wasn't great. I never was really sure if they understood the problem(s) even though I attempted to explain it. It wasn't my place and the project was basically done when we got involved. We just gave them a new means to distribute a product in a region they otherwise could not. They already had completed development on it (software wise).




Reply via email to