> IceCast recommends OGG but it does mention how to set up an MP3 stream
> http://www.icecast.org/docs/icecast-2.3.3/icecast2_basicsetup.html

Would streaming a patent-encumbered format infringe patents? I don't know. I would think not, but maybe I'm wrong.

> Both incorporate MuSE and allow it to stream out via IceCast.

I installed MuSE and I couldn't find the MP3 functionality (not saying it isn't there though).

> This is not a free software issue. The programs themselves are not recommending non-free software.

Maybe, but free software aims to give freedom to all of the community. Free software is about legal freedom as much as technical. A community in a country without copyright could potentially use leaked Windows source code to compile an OS that would free for them, but it wouldn't be free for the rest of the world.

Regarding patents, it seems that any software technique, format or design can be patented in the US these days. But there are some patents that stand out more than others, like the MP3 patents which are actively enforced.

However, I equally think having MP3-importing software is important, so that users can use free formats.

Maybe it would be better if patented software was in a separate repository, so that it would be easier for a Trisquel-based distro to not include it? The idea isn't too far-fetched (IMHO) - Fedora avoids including patented software, and users have to use third-party repos instead.

Anyway, that's my 2 cents.

Reply via email to