Wow, have you heard of the free software movement? Please check out the speeched of Richard Stallman at http://audio-video.gnu.org for some basic Free Software 101 which I'll try to cover here.

"he doesn't have the rights to those things"

On the contrary: One of the key tenets of the free software movement is that all software should be free. All as in all. :) So, I must disagree with you - They do have the right to the source code of all software that they receive so that they may have control over their computing, which brings up your next point.

"It was done legally"

It is unfortunate when people use the legal system to deny people their fundamental rights to have control over their own computing (and when this is done with the software inside medical devices that go inside your body like pacemakers and other things then you're being denied even control over your own body. See the talks that Karen Sandler has given on this topic.) Nevertheless, the free software movement says that it is wrong when someone denies someone these essential rights, even if it may be legal. That is what the movement is fighting for. Software freedom should be included in the United Nations's list of basic human rights. Let's go for it!

"If we say we have a right to what others, no matter how rich and rude they may be, have legally reserved to themselves, doesn't that amount to stealing?"

I am not referring to private copies of software, which people are entitled to, but only when that software is distributed to others. Once that happens the software should be free as to to respect the essential rights and autonomy of those that are receiving those copies.

Also, thinking that it's possible to "steal" software is a very dangerous line of thinking. See http://questioncopyright.org/minute_memes/copying_is_not_theft

Reply via email to