Thanks! Lembas and Magic Banana,

I was reviewing the Debian doc and saw a big error in my thinking, I thought it had suggested /usr be on a separate partition but it never does.

> ...one more partition whose use is to be estimated to avoid under/over-dimensioning
 but
"Any directory tree which a user has write permissions to, such as e.g. /home, /tmp and /var/tmp/, should be on a separate partition. This reduces the risk of a user DoS..."

It seems from the Audicity information that a /var/tmp partition required to address the DOS and Symlink concerns would need to be generous. Yes, I might like to make music someday. I suppose a 3d modeling program like Povray might be similar. I imagine they have some information indicating how big a /var/tmp partition would have to be.


I think I am arriving at some clarity, here's the new scheme but wll add maybe a 3 GB /var/tmp (also ext2)

|.................*.***extended partition***.*......................|..swap partition.|../home partition..|

../@16 GB../tmp@6 GB../var/log@1 GB../opt@3.2 GB |..swap@8 GB.....|../home @532 GB....|

..*ext4*...../...*ext2*...../....*ext4*........../.....*ext4*......|........ swap .........|......ext4.........|

I can hibernate if I want too, cause I just might want to if I can and also won't have to worry if I have room for movies.

This scheme would satisfy this - "Any directory tree which a user has write permissions to, such as e.g. /home, /tmp and /var/tmp/, should be on a separate partition. This reduces the risk of a user DoS..." and, if I understand, address Magic Banana's main point as well, if more room is needed in /usr, it's already there as long as / (/bin, /boot, /etc, /dev, /lib, lib64, /media, /mnt, /proc /run, sbin, /srv, /sys, /usr, /var - /var/log) doesn't exceed 16 GB there's room. And it seems like 16 GB should last quite a while. I only wonder if I were to install games in /opt if 3.2 GB would get strained.

There might be a performance hit if a partition is bigger than it needs to be but this scheme over all isn't very far over what I have now and I like it's performance fine. I think Centos and Fedora may have each had 40 GB / and they were fine also.

Reply via email to