What are you going on about? There's nothing wrong with the libre Radeon drivers. Linux-libre includes those, too.

If you're talking about the firmware, and saying that a libre kernel must be unable to load proprietary firmware, I have a news flash for you: not being able to load Radeon firmware isn't a design choice of Linux-libre, it's a side-effect of a choice to remove error messages when this firmware is unavailable. If preventing loading of firmware was a design choice, that would be a digital restriction mechanism, i.e. Linux-libre would be defective by design.

Additionally, Linux-libre can load proprietary firmware. It will happily load any firmware as long as it has the proper name and is a firmware file which has not had its references removed (i.e. there is a libre version of the firmware available). It just can't load firmware at all (libre or proprietary) if there is no libre firmware available.

Honestly, I think worrying about printing the name of a firmware file is a but much, so I think Debian's deblobbing process is better. But please don't mis-characterize the design goals of Linux-libre.

Reply via email to