On Fri, 2 Dec 2005 21:07:49 -0700 "Taylor" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
I'm curious about whether or not you see the contradiction in teaching Total Depravity on the one hand while ATST interpreting Romans 2:14,15 to mean that the unregenerate have God's Law written on their hearts? 
 
 
I'm not the one to be making this argument, Judy, as I do not ascribe to the classic doctrine of Total Depravity, which enlists a belief in "spiritual death." If, indeed, that doctrine were true, I would have to agree with you concerning the contradictory nature of your question. There would be no way for those who are literally dead to spiritual matters to have a guiding, inner awareness of God's law. And so, yours is a good question for someone else -- maybe our Calvinist friend from OZ :>)
 
It is my understanding that your belief is that Christians are still under God's law -- only now it is called the "law of Christ," which is even more demanding now than before. If this is so, then I am curious how is it that Paul in Romans 2 could be addressing Christians when he writes, "For when the Gentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having not the law, are a law unto themselves: Which shew the work of the law written in their hearts, ..." (14-15a). If they are Christians, then they would have the law, wouldn't they -- i.e., the law of Christ, with not one yod or serif having been removed?  Bill
 
Thank you for your response Bill
In answer to your question - Yes in our generation they could hold in their hands God's Law intact in written form but in every generation since the resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ - born again believers with understanding who walk after the Spirit do by nature the things contained in the law as per Rom 2:14,15.  This is the outworking of the Promise see Ezek 11:19-20; Ezek 36:26-27; Jer 31:33; Jer 32:40; Rom 2:14-15; Rom 8:2-4; in Jer 31:33, Heb 8:10; Heb 10:16.
 
 
 
Sent: Friday, December 02, 2005 7:11 AM
Subject: Re: [TruthTalk] Calvin's beliefs -

No problem Bill,
I'm curious about whether or not you see the contradiction in teaching Total Depravity on the one hand
while ATST interpreting Romans 2:14,15 to mean that the unregenerate have God's Law written on their
hearts?  Israel certainly did not have that benefit since they had to gather every 7yrs (men, women, children)
to hear it so that they wouldn't forget.  judyt
 
On Fri, 2 Dec 2005 06:10:59 -0700 "Taylor" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
 
Thanks for your responses, Judy. I was mainly just curious how you understood chapter 1 in relation to chapter 2. Your answers were clear and informative.
 
Bill
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, December 01, 2005 10:07 PM
Subject: Re: [TruthTalk] Calvin's beliefs -

 
 
On Thu, 1 Dec 2005 19:56:09 -0700 "Taylor" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:

Additional comments below in red.
From: Taylor
... rather than taking into consideration that the Gentiles in Romans 2 are in the church at Rome ...
 
Hi Judy,
 
What about Romans 1.18-32: did Paul write this in regards to the Christians in the Rome church? Were they the ones who were doing those things? Is this section about the Gentile Christians there, but not about the Jewish ones?
 
To me it appears as though Paul is giving an example of what happens when ppl (either Jews or Gentiles) in the Church hold the truth
in unrighteousness - IOW when they know the truth but continue practicing the lust of the flesh, eventually God turns them over to it since they love this wickedness more than they love God and His ways.
 
It would seem it is, since Paul moves immediately onto a rebuke of Jews in the first part of Chapter Two. And, of course, in that rebuke he charges them with having practiced the same things.
 
Apparently they have been judging ppl and Paul rebukes them for this.  I don't see it as necessarily related to the problems addressed
in Chapter 1. Jesus gives the same warning in Matt 7:1; many times we dislike in others what we dislike about ourselves..
 
Or maybe I should ask this: Do you consider the "O man" statements of Romans 2 to be in reference to Jews only and not to Gentiles also? Many commentators consider this ("O man") vocative to be Paul's way of directing his comments to Jews only. My question is, Do you agree with them?
 
No, I believe Paul is addressing the Church at Rome which consists of both Jew and Gentile but he does give the Jew special attention in Chapter 11.
 
Bill
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, December 01, 2005 9:23 AM
Subject: [TruthTalk] Calvin's beliefs -


All of this dialogue is ironic when one considers Calvins doctrine - which is that
because of God's Sovereignty - He has decreed everything .. So why did she not
allow God to deal with what He had Himself decreed?
 
There are so many contradictions.  Last night our DIL (who not so long ago came back
to church) and I attended a class where our pastor was attempting to enlighten us about
'Reformed doctrine' - Our DIL (who is a smart girl) came out of there thoroughly confused
because at the beginning he taught Total Depravity and last night he covered Romans
2:14,15 (same as JD would teach it) which is that these are pagan Gentiles - rather than
taking into consideration that the Gentiles in Romans 2 are in the church at Rome
(who the letter is written to) and that they might just possibly be born of the Spirit and have
a new regenerated nature as per Jer 31:33.  Our DIL was trying to figure out how these
'totally depraved Gentiles' have the law of God written on their hearts and do instinctively 
the things written therein. Amazing!!  No wonder ppl check their minds in at the door and
pick them up on the way out.
 

                                         judyt                                       
He that says "I know Him" and doesn't keep His Commandments
                              is a liar (1 John 2:4)
 

                                         judyt                                       
He that says "I know Him" and doesn't keep His Commandments
                              is a liar (1 John 2:4)
 

                                         judyt                                       
He that says "I know Him" and doesn't keep His Commandments
                              is a liar (1 John 2:4)

Reply via email to