> JD wrote:
>> Have I gone over your head with the
use
>> of this phrase? Look up ad hom and you
>> will
find "begging the question" in there
>> somewhere. You
have no idea just how
>> ridiculous this makes you
sound.
>
> Please stop attacking Judy!
PLEASE!
>
> You are plain wrong about this idea you have that "ad
hom" and "begging
> the
> question" are the same thing.
THEY ARE NOT. I don't have the time right
> now to educate you on
the differences. Maybe the moderator can help, or
> maybe you can
look it up for yourself. Furthermore, "begging the
>
question"
> is allowed on TruthTalk. It is not a good form of
argumentation, but you
> will not find me or any other moderator
reprimanding someone on the list
> for
> begging the
question. It is up to the TruthTalk members themselves to
>
recognize it and help others see the problem in their argumentation. The
> ad
> hominem argument is not allowed because e-mail is
sensitive to this
> fallacious form of argumentation in that it inflames
the emotions of
> others
> and causes posts like this one that
you just made.
>
> The reason you might have seen a list with
"begging the question" and "ad
> hom" together is because these are two
different forms of fallacious
> argumentation. You were probably
reading a list of fallacious arguments.
> THEY ARE NOT THE SAME.
Please correct your misunderstanding of these
> terms.
> Even if
your attacks upon Judy were allowed in this forum, you should do
>
so
> from an informed and educated position or you will be the one who
looks
> ridiculous.
>
> David Miller.
>
>
----------
> "Let your speech be always with grace, seasoned with salt,
that you may
> know how you ought to answer every man."
(Colossians 4:6)
>
http://www.InnGlory.org>
> If
you do not want to receive posts from this list, send an email to
>
[EMAIL PROTECTED] and
you will be unsubscribed. If you have a
> friend who wants to
join, tell him to send an e-mail to
>
[EMAIL PROTECTED] and he
will be subscribed.
>
