Shock and Awe in Pattani
Muslims Under Attack in Thailand
2004
The smell of blood hung over the Krue Se mosque... Its historic brick walls were
marred by hundreds of bullet holes. Its marble floors were gouged where
rocket-propelled grenades exploded. A torn, bloodstained Koran lay salvaged in the
courtyard� Muslim rebels chose to die Wednesday in a hail of lead and shrapnel rather
than surrender to police� To many, the dead were heroes.1 - Richard C. Paddock, Los
Angeles Times
Thai forces guard the bodies of slain Muslims
In the aftermath of September 11 and the Bali bombings of October 2002, Southeast Asia
came into focus as a �second front� in the war against international terrorism. The
arrests of dozens of suspected Al-Qaeda operatives in Singapore, Malaysia, and the
Philippines, as well as the presence of groups such as the Jemaah Islamiah (JI), Abu
Sayyaf, Laskar Jihad, and the Kumpulan Mujahideen Malaysia (KMM) signaled to US
strategists and policymakers that militant Islam had made significant headway into
that part of the world.2
In February 2002, an FBI report called Malaysia a �primary operational launch pad� for
the September 11 attacks, and some US analysts drew comparisons between the
Philippine�s Abu Sayyaf and the Taliban in Afghanistan3. Exaggerations and rhetoric
aside, Southeast Asia is definitely a region of deep-seated historical grievances and
simmering ethno-religious animosities that manifest in sporadic outbursts of extreme
violence between Muslims and non-Muslims.
Recent weeks saw two bloody clashes involving Muslims in Southeast Asia. After two
years of relative calm, violence exploded once again between Muslims and Christians in
Ambon, the administrative center of Indonesia�s Moluccas islands. Tens were killed and
hundreds injured, with buildings, homes and places of worship destroyed by rioters and
rival militias.
During the same week, 108 Muslims were slain by police in Thailand�s southern province
of Pattani. Thai officials claim that the youth attacked several police stations and
checkpoints in an attempt to steal firearms. However, regional police commander Prung
Boonpadung pointed out that most of the dead were teenagers. Sources also pointed out
that the young Islamist were armed only with machetes and a few guns.4
Alerted in advance of the attack, Thai security forces gunned down tens of the
Islamists. Facing almost certain defeat at the hands of heavily armed police, the
young rebels retreated to a 16th century mosque, one of the holiest Islamic sites in
Thailand.5 Police surrounded the mosque and called on the Islamists to surrender. When
they refused, Thai forces fired hundreds of bullets and grenades into the mosque. The
assault left the mosque awash in blood and left none of the Islamists alive.
---------------------------------
The Thai assault left the mosque awash in blood and left none of the Islamists alive.
---------------------------------
In an attempt to preserve Thailand�s normal image as a peaceful tourist destination,
Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra dismissed the Islamist attack as the work of
local gangs. Tourism is Thailand�s primary source of income, with 11 million visitors
every year.6 However, a Pattanese separatist group issued a call to arms to Muslims
living in the south of Thailand, where an insurgency has been waged sporadically for
four decades. statement. The statement, posted on the Pattani United Liberation
Organization (PULO) website, called for a Muslim uprising and warned foreigners to
stay away from Thailand�s top tourist destinations. �We are calling all of you to rise
up against the Siamese (Thais),� the PULO statement read, describing the government�s
treatment of Muslims as �terrorism.�7
The Historical Roots of Conflict
Thailand is a predominantly Buddhist nation of around 60 million people. Almost 10% of
the population is Muslims, living mostly in the five southern provinces bordering
Malaysia.8 Most Muslims in southern Thailand are ethnic Malay who speak a dialect
known as Yawi. They constitute a majority in the three southern provinces of Yala,
Pattani and Songkhla. Although there is no precise date for the introduction of Islam
to Thailand, it is evident that Southeast Asia�s initial contact with Islam was
through Arab traders in the region as early as the 8th century AD.9
Eventually, Arab and Persian pioneers settled in Thailand, setting up businesses,
taking local wives and bringing up their children according to the principles of
Shari�ah law. In time, they were joined by their Indian coreligionists, and by the
latter half of the 10th century there was an established Muslim community in
Thailand.10 Between the 12th and 15th centuries Islam spread extensively, with large
numbers of people converting, including the King of Pattani, who declared an �Islamic
kingdom� in 1457.11
A Pattanese Muslim holds a bloodied religious book
The subsequent Islamization of Pattani replaced many elements of the Hindu-Buddhist
culture, and the Muslim religious elite came to dominate the kingdom�s sociopolitical
system. However, the Muslim dynasty was abolished in 1786 when Pattani was conquered
by the Kingdom of Siam. Under Siamese rule, Muslim provinces were governed by
Siamese-appointed bureaucrats working under a centralized administrative structure.
Muslim rebellions in opposition to Siam�s administrative �reforms� were suppressed.
The subsequent Anglo-Siamese Treaty of 1909 guaranteed Siam�s undisputed control over
Pattani, following which the Siamese government took various measures aimed at
weakening the Islamic identity of the Pattanese to develop a mono-ethnic, Buddhist,
Thai state.12
Under Siamese rule, the local governors of the Muslim-majority provinces were replaced
by Thai rulers. In addition, an act was passed in 1921 forcing Muslims to attend
Siamese schools to receive a secular education. As a result, Islamic schools were
closed and the power of Muslim scholars was greatly undermined.
During World War II, the Thai military regime of Pibul Songkhram initiated a series of
policies aimed at the forcible assimilation of Muslims. The wearing of western-style
trousers was made compulsory for men, and Muslims were prevented from adopting Muslim
names or using the Malay dialect. In addition, Shari�ah law was set aside in favor of
the Thai Buddhist laws of marriage and inheritance.13
Such policies generated a great deal of resentment among the Muslim population of
Thailand. Consequently, Haji Sulong, the president of the Islamic Religious Council,
submitted a seven-point list of demands to the Thai government, calling for an end to
the government�s discriminatory policies. The Thai government responded by arresting
Haji Sulong and his associates and charging them with treason.
---------------------------------
Muslims constitute 10% of the population of Thailand.
---------------------------------
By the end of World War II the Thai state had militarily subdued the Pattani
separatist movement.14 In the initial post-war period, the government tried to adopt a
more conciliatory stance towards Muslims in the south. But centuries of
marginalization and suppression at the hands of Thai officials, state penetration of
Muslim civil society and the absence of Pattanese political participation contributed
to mutual antagonism between both sides. This antagonism erupted on April 28, 1948, in
a pivotal event known as the Dusun Nyiur incident - a violent clash between Thai
police and Pattanese Muslims that left an estimated 1,100 Muslims and 30 policemen
killed and set the stage for the rise of more militant Muslim separatist groups.15
The Dynamics of Muslim Separatism
Modern Islamic insurgent movements in southern Thailand, the southern Philippines and
Aceh arguably represent the most visible signs of armed separatism in Southeast Asia
today. The roots of ethno-religious unrest in each of these regions stem from the same
basic factors: insensitivity to local concerns, regional neglect, military repression
and forcible attempts to impose uniformity of language and social behavior on entire
communities.16
Armed separatist movements in Southeast Asia represent a serious, pervasive and
notably persistent phenomenon. This is evident in the phenomenon�s duration and
severity, as well as its resistance to negotiated settlements. For example, the war in
Mindanao between Muslim separatists and the Philippines government has been ongoing
for decades, causing some 100,000 casualties and creating over 500,000 refugees. More
importantly, in all cases of separatism, one can detect the clash between the dominant
group and its cultural values and the subordinate one with its own religious-cultural
identification. National identity is invariably defined in terms of �the dominant
group�s values and culture, with other groups on the periphery tending to be left
out.�17
Heavily armed Thai forces at Krue Se mosque
The Pattanese rebellion in southern Thailand in the post-World War II period is the
case of a Muslim Malay minority, with its distinct culture, traditions, history and
language, trying to break free from the vestiges of a dominant Buddhist Thai culture.
The heavy-handed and often insensitive attempts by central authorities to impose
Thai-Buddhist culture on the Muslims have resulted in Pattanese resentment and a fear
of losing their own identity to the Thai, perceived as foreigners or intruders.18
Additionally, the underdeveloped nature of southern Thailand relative to the rest of
the country has contributed greatly to Muslim feelings of deprivation and
marginalization. In fact, Muslim provinces account for only 1.5% of Thailand�s gross
domestic product. The south has virtually no industry, the infrastructure is abysmal
and tourism is underdeveloped despite extensive natural beauty.19
Two principal militant groups remain active in southern Thailand: PULO and New PULO.
Both organizations operate independently and have been largely unwilling to coordinate
their activities due to differences in their strategic outlooks. However, the two
groups managed to coordinate a series of attacks (codenamed �Falling Leaves�) aimed at
killing state workers, government officials, law enforcement personnel and attacking
symbols of Thai Buddhist repression. Between August 1997 and January 1998, no less
than 33 separate attacks were carried out as part of this shared effort, resulting in
nine deaths, several dozen injuries, and considerable economic damage.
---------------------------------
Muslims were prevented from adopting Muslim names or using the Malay dialect.
---------------------------------
PULO is the largest and most prominent of the Malay Muslim groups in southern
Thailand, operating since the 1960s. The group was established in 1968 by Kabir Abdul
Rahman - an Islamic scholar disillusioned by the ineffectuality of the established
Malay opposition in Pattani. His group brought together �a younger, more militant
generation of Thai Muslims many of whom had been radicalized while studying overseas -
becoming an active insurgency with the politicization of Malay students in the mid- to
late 1970s.�20
PULO�s insurgent activities are carried out by the movement�s armed wing, the Pattani
United Liberation Army (PULA), which directs the majority of its attacks against Thai
government buildings and cultural and educational facilities in the south. New PULO
emerged as a dissident faction of PULO in 1995. The group has pursued the goal of
Pattanese self-autonomy, albeit �through less dramatic but more consistent actions
than its parent organization.�21
Conclusions
The most recent episode of carnage against Muslims in Pattani will doubtless have
significant internal repercussions. The Thai government has thus far failed to realize
that heavy-handed security-based approaches end up radicalizing oppressed communities
and increasing popular support for resistance groups. The US invasion of Afghanistan
and Iraq and the continuing presence of foreign troops in many Muslim societies have
already worked to radicalize the Muslim community in Thailand and increase their
awareness of global Muslim grievances.
This increased awareness contributed to the Pattanese perception that Thai oppression
against them is part and parcel of a global campaign aimed at suppressing Muslims
worldwide.22 Last year, reports indicated that the US was seeking to establish a
military base in Thailand to help government forces combat Muslim separatists.23 If
the US eventually takes an active role in suppressing Muslims in the south, the global
confrontation between Muslims and the US will definitely widen. Moreover, the
crackdown on Pattanese Muslims may also have an impact throughout Southeast Asia due
to the multiple ideological and logistical linkages between Muslim separatists
operating in the region.
Given recent US war crimes in Iraq and America�s insistence on militarily confronting
Islamist groups throughout the world, Al-Qaeda�s ideology will definitely become more
prevalent among oppressed Muslims worldwide. As Jason Burke noted in a recent Foreign
Policy article: �al-Qaeda is more lethal as an ideology than as an organization.
�al-Qaedaism� will continue to attract supporters in the years to come - whether Osama
Bin Laden is around to lead them or not.�24
==================================================
"And what is wrong with you that you fight not in the Cause of Allah, and for those
weak, ill-treated and oppressed among men, women, and children, whose cry is: "Our
Lord! Rescue us from this town whose people are oppressors; and raise for us from You
one who will protect, and raise for us from You one who will help." (The Quran 4:75)
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! - Internet access at a great low price.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ---------------------~-->
Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo! Companion Toolbar.
Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free!
http://us.click.yahoo.com/L5YrjA/eSIIAA/yQLSAA/TcOolB/TM
---------------------------------------------------------------------~->
Memetakan Tumpat dalam IT.
http://edi.bebto.com
http://panduan.7p.com
E-mel web base percuma untuk warga Tumpat
http://tumpat.mail.everyone.net/email/scripts/loginuser.pl
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Tumpat/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
