One comment inline.

  Simon

Simon Laws wrote:

A concern with that is we're then not shipping anything prebuilt for
webapps
or webapp samples...and the majority of the users we have posting on the
user list seem more interested in running in webapps and tomcat than
standalone.

 ...ant



webapp does seem to be the environment that is most talked about. In
particular combining tuscany and the sca application into a war (which is
what we show in the samples).  What do you mean by prebuilt? Do you mean
your new approach of having a tomcat war.

for the case where tuscany is included in the webapp itself our current
approach with the binary distribution lets a developer

download tuscany distribution
* configure development environment to allow tuscany to be included in the
webapp
   We have ant scripts in the samples
   I believe Sebastien's Eclipse integration allows for this but I haven't
tried it
build the war including the sca application
copy war to tomcat

The value of this is that it allows a Tuscany webapp to be redistributed
and run on a standard Tomcat with no pre-configuration to install Tuscany.
This might be needed for some production environments, but it isn't the way
a developer would want to work.  The distro is targeted at developers, so
we shouldn't include pre-built samples in it that use this approach.

  Simon

for the case where tuscany provides a war that runs in tomcat and allows
contributions to be deployed by dropping them in.

download tuscany distribution
* configure tomcat by copying the tuscany war in
build sca appplication as a separate contribution
copy application to tuscany webapp directory

In both cases there is the notion of configuring the environment (*). This
step could be the selection of a different distribution and the unpacking of
it. It could also be supported with a single distribution that is unpacked
and suitably configured (manually or with a tool).

Are you thinking of some magic that that allows this to work more
effectively with separate distributions?

Simon




---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to