On 11/1/07, ant elder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 11/1/07, Raymond Feng <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > Hi, > > > > Please review and vote on the 1.0.1-incubating release artifacts of > > Tuscany SCA for Java. > > > > The RC3 contains a few fixes to issues discovered in RC2 (build.xml for > > web apps, distributed calculator and excesssive jars). Thank you for > > reporting and fixing the issues promptly. > > > > SVN Tag: > > > http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/tags/java/sca/1.0.1-RC3/ > > > > Stage maven repo: http://people.apache.org/~rfeng/tuscany/maven/ > > > > RAT report: > > http://people.apache.org/~rfeng/tuscany/1.0.1-RC3/1.0.1-RC3.rat.txt > > > > Distros (zip/gz/asc/md5) : > > http://people.apache.org/~rfeng/tuscany/1.0.1-RC3/ > > > > Thanks, > > Raymond > > > > > +1 > > The one main issue is that the Jettison copyright is missing from the > NOTICE > file (it is in the LICENSE file but should be in the NOTICE instead). This > should be fixed if there's a respin. If someone was being pedantic they > could maybe block the release for this so its a gamble taking it on to the > IPMC. I'd probably risk it but up to you to decide :) > > None of the rest are blockers: > > That RAT report attached to the vote email looks like an old one, but I've > run it locally and can't see anything serious, couple of new missing > license > headers. > > LICENSE file issues: commons-cli, commons-discovery and xbean aren't > included in the list of AL components, j2ee-management has the wrong > version > now, jettison shouldn't be listed separately but just included in the list > of AL components. > > The maven repo artifacts are not signed, can just sign them while the > votes > are continuing on. > > The bin distro INSTALL file mentions a doc folder but we no longer have > that > > Running the calculator sample has logging output mixed in with the sample > output, so the README output is wrong. I think we should remove the > logging > to keep the sample as simple as possible. > > Something is dragging in axiom dependencies so for example all the webapp > sample war's includes axiom and all its dependencies. > > The helloworld-dojo and jsonrpc sample Ant build scripts includes a duff > jar > name: tuscany-databinding-json-1.0.1-incubating.jar-SNAPSHOT.jar, so the > Ant > built artifacts don't work. > > I'm about to go in leave so don't have time to try all of the samples > sorry > but all the other ones i have tried look good running and building ok. > > ...ant > I've just been through most of the samples/demos. This is what I found
demos: alert-aggregator-webapp - fails as it needs the definitions-xml dependency adding to build.xml bigbank - all the parts run up but I get no response from the getAccountReport button. Haven't investigated yet xml-bigbank - ant compile fails as build.xml doesn't create tartget/classes if it doesn't already exit. Workaround is to create it manually. samples: helloworld-bpel - NPE to do with file io, haven't investigated helloworld-dojo-webapp - see ant's comment above helloworld-jsonrpc-webapp - see ant's comment above helloworld-ws-reference-jms - ant run doesn't work, README is wrong. We should remove this sample helloworld-ws-service-secure - ships with a work directory. Should filter it out While none of these are a big deal in their own right because 3 out of our 4 demos don't work out of the box I'm -1. Regards Simon
