On Mon, 28 Jun 2010 03:12:39 am Adam Bark wrote:
> I think the 'as' syntax is only available in Python 3.x
You think wrong. It is available from Python 2.6 onwards.
> Question marks go at the end of the sentence where you would normally
> put a full stop if it wasn't a question.
That's a terribly unhelpful answer given the context of Payal's
question. I'm sure he knows the grammatical rules for questions in
ordinary English sentences, but he's asking specifically about a
particular form of sentence where you have a question consisting of two
or more alternatives or examples separated as paragraphs:
[example]
Hello, which is better, a lambda:
(1) lambda x: x+1
or a function definition:
(2) def f(x):
return x+1?
[end example]
It is very reasonable to ask where to put the question mark in examples
like this. Unfortunately there is no good answer. If you put it on the
same line as the second example, as shown, certainly isn't correct
because it makes the question mark part of the example. It's
*especially* dangerous in a programming context, because it leads to a
syntax error.
Putting it on a line on it's own after the example looks silly.
Re-writing the question to avoid the problem is often awkward, but can
be done:
[rewritten example]
Hello, which of these two are better?
(1) lambda x: x+1
(2) def f(x):
return x+1
[end rewritten example]
Since there is no One Right Answer, you can do whichever seems best in
context.
--
Steven D'Aprano
_______________________________________________
Tutor maillist - Tutor@python.org
To unsubscribe or change subscription options:
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/tutor
