On 04/12/11 07:47, surya k wrote:
I don't understand why python doesn't provide executable files for the
source code.
> 1. Why doesn't python doesn't offer executable file ?
Because python is an interpreted language like Java, early Visual Basic
and many other languages. It would be difficult to build a true native
machine code compiler for Python and still retain the features that make
it so productive. Some partial compilers exist but they cannot cover all
of the features of the language. As programmers we have to make the
trade-off of speed of development versus speed of execution, memory
usage, ease of deployment and many other factors. This is what engineers
do in any type of engineering, software engineering is no different.
It's all about choosing the most appropriate compromise for the problem
at hand.
I am using py2exe for building executables and I found that, it doesn't
completely change code into binary but creates dll files and python
libraries to run that particular code. This process makes program very
large although it isn't.
Define large?
It's not usually very large compared to things like Microsoft Office or
even single applications like Photoshop. Compare the size of Visio
against the Python open source equivalent: Dia.
And remember that if you had to code up in C all the things you get as
part of the Python language your short program would be much much
bigger. A program's real size is determined by the functions it performs
not the number of lines of source code. (If you want an objective
measure calculate the Function Point metric) So yes, for trivial
programs Pythons overheads will be higher than, say , C. But for real
world applications the differences will be much less, and Python will
often be smaller. And if the Python interpreter is already installed
even small apps become comparable.
2. If one wants to make a commercial software using python, how can he
hide the code?
Use py2exe... Or only deploy the compiled modules (.pyc) or rely on a
license agreement and the threat of litigation. Is hiding the source
code a necessary thing? For many years it was common for commercial
applications to come with the source code. In fact the very first PC
that I used came with a manual containing the full assembler listing of
the BIOS... It is a relatively modern idea that we should try to hide
how our code works from the userts. And it is mainly paranoia that makes
us think that not shipping source code makes our programs "safe" from
copying. It is the ideas and concepts of code that need protecting - via
patents - not the source. Just compare how many office apps are out
there. Very similar to use but very different source code. Its easy to
recreate a feature once you see how it works. Hiding the source makes
very little difference and provided you have legal protection
you can sue anyone who steals your code - after all they will have the
same difficulty!
3. However, if one wants to make an open source software, as python
doesn't offer executable files, how people make those so as to
distribute their products to people?
Just take a look at the many open source applications written in Python.
Essentially its the same as applications written in Java or .NET. The
user has to install the execution environment ass wekl as the app. But
they only need to do it once. And in Linux and MacOS Python is already
installed alongside Java and Perl etc.
But we have already given you all of this information in replies to your
previous post on the same theme a few days ago.
And to pick up on your subject line, Python is used extensively in "the
real world" in many areas outside of developing shrink-wrapped
commercial applications. If you are writing bespoke code for a contract
then the client will expect you to provide the source code as normal
practice. And provided the app does what was asked and runs quickly
enough they are unlikely to care that it was written in Python (in
factthey may prefer it since Python is comparatively easy to maintain).
Similarly. Python is used in many large scale IT operations to provide
support and test tools (Google being a good example) or for rapid
prototyping.
You can find many examples of real-world Python on the Python.org
website, just look under success stories:
http://www.python.org/about/success/
And browse the job adverts...
http://www.python.org/community/jobs/
--
Alan G
Author of the Learn to Program web site
http://www.alan-g.me.uk/
_______________________________________________
Tutor maillist - Tutor@python.org
To unsubscribe or change subscription options:
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/tutor
