Brooks Harris via tz wrote in <[email protected]>: |On 2026-10-16 07:54 AM, Michelle Bastian wrote: |> There was a recorded message from the ITU-T saying they are in full \ |> support. The IERS recorded message also gave their support, and their \ |> commitment to keep providing UT1. |> |> Re the one hour difference being supposedly non-controversial, as \ |> Tim pointed out. This seems to be the response to those who raised \ |> questions about the broader public, and whether standards bodies \ |> had the right to make civil time discontinuous with Earth rotation \ |> in this way. It does make me think of this claim from Pavel Gabor \ |> at the 2017 Science of Time conference, who advised many of these \ |> bodies this way: |> |> "It is imperative to allow the general public to perceive civil time \ |> as a reflection of astronomical phenomena. In practice, claim that \ |> you intend to maintain the coupling between civil time and Earth’s \ |> rotation in the long run. Never speak of “abolishing” or “suppressing” \ |> or “discontinuing” the leap second. Always maintain that the measure \ |> is temporary" |> |> The one hour alignment allows us to keep the idea that there hasn't \ |> been an absolute decoupling.. |> |> This was my take on it...https://theconversation.com/experts-have-voted-\ |> to-stop-adding-extra-seconds-to-clock-time-the-outcome-favours-big-tech-\ |> 294297
Btw i posted two emails to the leapseconds list, but which were silenty discarded (it seems). I personally find the "social togetherness", the "common feel" on such events important. I said Steffen Nurpmeso wrote in <20261012134120.Km9uZWc9@steffen%sdaoden.eu>: |Brooks Harris via groups.io wrote in | <[email protected]>: ||On 2026-10-11 11:15 PM, Warner Losh wrote: ||> On Sat, Oct 10, 2026 at 7:31 AM Brooks Harris via groups.io <brooks= ||> [email protected]> wrote: ||> ||>> CIPM ||>> Agenda - Day 3 (Thursday 15 October 2026) ||>> 2. Continuous UTC ||>> https://www.bipm.org/en/cgpm-2026/agenda-day-3 ||>> ||> So leap seconds stop early because a negative leapsecond could be \ ||> coming. .. ||My impression is that "fear of negative leap-seconds" is a recent ||additional motivation to get rid of leap-seconds urgently. But this ||debate has been going on since at least 1999, motivated by the ||inconvenience of incorporating leap-seconds into timekeeping ||calculations, especially as compared to the simplicity of ignoring ||leap-seconds as most POSIX/NTP based systems do. | |It is the ongoing effort to overcome cultural and philosphical |reasoning for a mechanical beneficiary. |I say that is a massive decay of value. |You say 1999, and i say it was careless from the specialist-, and |ill-advised by the decision making side not to spread the word of |TAI so that everyone has an easy access to it. Have they. |I say computers should have a computer time, and mankind should |uphold the scientific achievement of being able to track time so |good, over Stonehenge (or even older, here and there) to today; |the social event of getting informed of an upcoming leap second |alone, if appropriately appreciated, which it hm almost was here |where i live; and i think other nations more so even. |Man what do i say, if i look at the night sky i only ever see |those f...ing satellites, what a mess. (They currently cross |Beteigeuze, Aldebaran, Riegel, Sirius, Capella, Saturn, and yes, |also that s....y hostile red dwarf mars, no harm in that.) ... --End of <20261012134120.Km9uZWc9@steffen%sdaoden.eu> and Steffen Nurpmeso wrote in <20261013125118.CTdcC7-O@steffen%sdaoden.eu>: |Despite my more valuable message being lost without trace somehow |(until now) | |Brooks Harris via groups.io wrote in ||On 2026-10-12 02:07 PM, Warner Losh wrote: ... ||> Yea. Time_t not being able to uniquely encode leap seconds is why \ ||> I started ||> advocating against them in the early 2000s. I never thought I'd see \ ||> the day ||> it would become a reality. | ||I've always been in the "keep the leap-second" camp because it ||(approximately) honors the ancient tradition of keeping solar time by ||the position of the Sun in the sky. I still am, but I may be out voted. | |Me too. |And insisting on the jointly experienced a.k.a. "social event". | ||(I do understand that POSIX time_t skips leap-seconds, the root of the ||debate in the first place.) | |No, there is CLOCK_MONOTONIC, and it is there for a long time. | | Reference to CLOCK_MONOTONIC is added in the description of | {_POSIX_CLOCKRES_MIN} for alignment with IEEE Std 1003.1j-2000. | |Long time. |Availability of CLOCK_TAI is unfortunately still not standardized. |But hey -- as far as i know, CLOCK_TAI does not have leapseconds. | ||It's not a done deal yet. We'll see what the CIPM actually does. Then it ||goes over to ITU-R, who, as I understand it, is revising ITU-R TF 460, ||dividing it into two parts. I don't have access to those deliberations. ||But the topic will probably be discussed sometime between 2027-02-22 and ||2027-03-04 when WP 7A next meets: ||ITU-R Events ||https://www.itu.int/en/events/Pages/Calendar-Events.aspx?sector=ITU-R ... --End of <20261013125118.CTdcC7-O@steffen%sdaoden.eu> --steffen | |Der Kragenbaer, The moon bear, |der holt sich munter he cheerfully and one by one |einen nach dem anderen runter wa.ks himself off |(By Robert Gernhardt)
