On 10/17/2026 2:01 PM, Brian Inglis via tz wrote:
Non-solar timekeeping is a legal quagmire in English common-law jurisdictions, and may also be with religious regimes, so is likely to become a political issue, making it remotely possible that tzdb may have to track jurisdictions that have dropped/still use leap seconds, similar to DST, just as some are starting to drop that!
I hope we do not get to the point where time offsets between countries or cities within countries are defined by seconds. It could lead to a situation where the number and effective time of each leap second would need to be tracked per jurisdiction (not just a do they or don't they observe leap seconds).
Solar time would make the issue worse. Vancouver defining their time as UTC-08:12:28, Calgary UTC-07:36:16, Regina UTC-06:58:28, Winnipeg UTC-06:28:33. Golden BC assigned UTC-07:47:52? Would one change their clocks every few miles that they traveled east or west just to support some arbitrary rule that claimed "clock noon must be at solar noon"? Would one change their clocks on a daily basis to account for the natural shift in solar noon? Solar noon drifts about 30 minutes from the earliest to latest time. 20th century time keeping synchronized civil time away from "high noon".
What began as something convenient for railroads became convenient for technologies introduced later. We now have globally synchronized time transmitted by radio and satellite (and the Internet). Solar time would be a huge step backward. For both the technology that relies on globally synchronized time (with reasonable regionally defined offsets) and the people who rely on such technology.
