James, Thank you for looking over the maps. Of all places, I did not expect questions about Coats Island... but sure, I will try to answer.
The description on the Wikimedia Commons page (underneath the map) says: "This map depicts observed time zones and observed time zone boundaries, some of which differ from those defined by provincial and territorial legislation. In areas with no road network and no inhabitants, the map falls back to using legislated time zone boundaries." Coats Island is not inhabited, but there are reportedly two bird research camps located on the island. One of the camps, with four small buildings, can be seen here: https://maps.app.goo.gl/eqQhRTJuX5hKZJxLA Wikipedia says that Inuit from Coral Harbour visit to harvest walrus. That is about all I can tell you about the island. Given that nobody lives on the island permanently, and given that researchers or hunters may arrive from different places and for different purposes, I do not think it would be reasonable to declare the existence of an observed time zone. For the purposes of the map, this means falling back to legislated time zone boundaries. The relevant time legislation states: "in relation to that part of Nunavut that is east of the 85th meridian of west longitude, and in Southampton Island and the islands adjacent to Southampton Island, Eastern Standard Time, being five hours behind Greenwich time;" As with a lot of Canadian legislation, the wording is very much open to interpretation! There are two islands that I thought seemed close enough to be considered as being "adjacent". Both are uninhabited. Qikiqtaaluk (White Island): located 1.2 km from Southampton Island Caribou Island: located 2.8 km from Southampton Island. Coats Island is located about 70 km from Southampton Island across cold open sea. I do not consider Coats Island and Southampton Island to be adjacent. Some of you reading this on the mailing list may ask: why does it matter what the time zone on an uninhabited Arctic island is? The real answer is that it does not matter, and visitors can set their watches as they please. However, when I apply shading to an island on the map, I need to choose one colour or another; if I did not choose any colour, the island would be the same shade of blue as the sea. -chris On Sun, Nov 1, 2026 at 2:00 PM James Bellaire <[email protected]> wrote: > On 10/31/2026 11:27 PM, Chris Walton via tz wrote: > > Tim and James, > > I agree that there are tons of errors on most of the Canadian time > > zone maps out there. The Time Zone Hell maps are better than some, > > but they are not perfect. > > > > I do try, however, to make sure that my maps on Wikimedia Commons are > > as accurate as possible. If you believe there are any boundary or > > colouring errors on these maps please let me know. > > It is the most accurate that I have seen. > > My only question would be Coats Island, uninhabited and part of the > Kivalliq Region. The Nunavut Time Zone Regulations specifies > "Southampton Island and the islands adjacent to Southampton Island, > Eastern Standard > Time". Coats Island was originally thought to be part of Southampton > Island and it seems that the people who visit there come from > Southampton Island. But most maps I see place it in Iqaluit Time. Not > close enough to be considered "adjacent"? > >
