On 2026-11-12 20:19, James Bellaire via tz wrote:
On 11/12/2026 8:24 PM, Aoun Khan via tz wrote:
I think you're ignoring the main point here: BC's new Pacific Time is just a name. MST is the same exact time zone, it's just a more universal name that is used beyond British Columbia. BC already has a TZ name (i.e. America/Vancouver).

Yukon doesn't go by PCT for example. Provinces and territories are artificially creating different provinces (ABT vs. NWT Time).

Paul has suggested an option that would remove "MST" from BC, "CST" from Alberta/NWT and "EST" from Manitoba. The use of "-07", "-06" and "-05", respectively.

CLDR has bypassed the issue by using "PDT", "MDT" and "CDT" year round. Even though it is odd to have a xDT without an xST.

While there is some importance to local usage there is also the issue of not using names that would confuse people outside the region who may want to do business with those in the region. "Pacific Time" for an area adjacent to another "Pacific Time" (shared land border) is confusing. Which is why "PDT",  "MST" or "-07" or would be better understood by contacts outside of the zone.

There may be some confusion in the fall when scheduling a meeting at "PDT" and assuming (incorrectly) that Vancouver fell back. A little education ("Vancouver doesn't fall back any more") and the person outside the zone knows the difference between PST in Seattle and PDT in Vancouver. "MST" fits the use in north eastern BC and Yukon, but is apparently more confusing locally than expected (for those using software that actually shows the tzdb zone). The best solution returns to numeric "-07".

In the latest 2026f build checks, checknow.awk advised for zonenow.tab:

zones America/Phoenix     and America/Vancouver identical from now on
zones America/Mexico_City and America/Edmonton  identical from now on
zones America/Jamaica     and America/Winnipeg  identical from now on

In zonenow.tab (current time correct only going forward) on 2026-11-01

        America/Vancouver was merged into America/Phoenix
        America/Edmonton  was merged into America/Mexico_City
        America/Winnipeg  was merged into America/Jamaica

as those other zones have had those offsets for longest, and/or have larger populations than the legacy Canadian zones:

https://lists.iana.org/hyperkitty/list/[email protected]/thread/CBEK3HXYBOXGD34ZFDSF64QIDT7ZWGBB/
* zonenow.tab
(America/Vancouver): Remove; now coalesced with America/Phoenix.
(America/Edmonton):  Remove; now coalesced with America/Mexico_City.
(America/Winnipeg):  Remove; now coalesced with America/Jamaica.
Update comments accordingly.

--
Take care. Thanks, Brian Inglis              Calgary, Alberta, Canada

La perfection est atteinte                   Perfection is achieved
non pas lorsqu'il n'y a plus rien à ajouter  not when there is no more to add
mais lorsqu'il n'y a plus rien à retrancher  but when there is no more to cut
                                -- Antoine de Saint-Exupéry

Reply via email to