I am only here because I thought this would be the place where a correction 
could be found for the problem I noticed last week that my server was reporting 
Mountain Standard Time (MST).  Our region has never used Mountain Standard 
Time. This was — it seemed — an obvious mistake or error. It turns out it was a 
choice. It is one that needs to be corrected and I’ll go beyond this list if I 
have to to have it corrected not because of some personal opinion, but because 
the reality for people on the ground and the law of the land states that 
Mountain Standard Time is not correct. And according to the RFC that governs 
this list, those two things are what are supposed to set the timezone 
conventions in tzdata.

"Common English abbreviations used in media across a region are supported,”
Taking a poll of abbreviations used in media around the BC region (again):

National Research Council of Canada Official Time Clock 
<https://nrc.canada.ca/en/certifications-evaluations-standards/canadas-official-time>:
 PDT (which itself says this is under review and refers to Provincial and 
Territorial governments for official timezones)
BC Government 
<https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/governments/celebrating-british-columbia/daylight-saving-time>:
 PCT
Environment Canada 
<https://weather.gc.ca/en/location/index.html?coords=49.245,-123.115>: PCT
CBC 
<https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/kelowna-airport-fees-9.7425416>:
 PDT
CTV 
<https://www.ctvnews.ca/vancouver/vancouver-island/article/el-nino-warming-reaches-deep-waters-off-bc-coast-scientists-say/>:
 using EST times
GlobalBC 
<https://globalnews.ca/news/12154854/filipino-bc-audit-lapu-lapu-tragedy-response-compared-tumbler-ridge-school-shooting/>:
 no timezone specified.
ChekNews/CanadianPress 
<https://cheknews.ca/meat-cheese-and-luxury-clothes-among-top-targets-for-retail-thieves-police-1361980/>:
 no timezone specified.

1) These changes have been anticipated and expected by the public for more than 
6 years.
2) Canada, as a sovereign country, gets to decide its timezones. This is the 
first time in over 100 years that *some* of those timezone may differ from 
others in North America.
3) In the case of using Mountain Standard Time in the Pacific region, the 
deviation from the norm “Pacific” is not from government policy change.

Cheers
Chris


> On Nov 17, 2026, at 13:34, Brian Inglis via tz <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> On 2026-11-17 10:24, mark--- via tz wrote:
>> Living in central BC, I can tell you that I don't think MST is catching on 
>> any time soon and will lead to many confusions. The mountains are in the 
>> East. Different time zone. We are Pacific Time.
>> Now - I do see the hesitation of adopting PCT until it's clear what the US 
>> states in the Pacific time zone will be doing and if everyone can agree on 
>> naming scheme: keep switching as is for the foreseeable future, staying on 
>> PST - I mean it means standard 🤷‍♂️, or switch to permanent PDT as well. 
>> Seeing PDT in computer programs is a bit unsettling since it feels at some 
>> point it would switch back, but MST just feels wrong. Just seeing -7 when I 
>> select Vancouver isn't the greatest, but would at least give me more 
>> confidence than seeing MST or PDT. How about PPT - Pacific Permanent Time 😉
> 
> These anecdotes spamming the list about personal confusion and opinions and 
> suggestions for alternatives are confused about the purpose of the mailing 
> list and the database.
> 
> The purpose of the database is to encode the rules within its limits, which 
> the maintainer has extended to allowing extreme values to accomodate 
> politicians and bureaucrats decisions and rules.
> 
> Common English abbreviations used in media across a region are supported, but 
> where they are not used, numeric %z zone output is the default, and in case 
> of any disagreement, are used to permanently settle the issue in place of any 
> alphabetic abbreviations!
> 
> So keep spamming the list and the output may be permanently changed to 
> numeric %z output: -07/-06/-05 across western, or possibly all, Canadian 
> zones, to avoid any possible opinions or alternatives in future.
> 
> Will that be less confusing to those of you who want to see their personal 
> opinion or their local government's as output?
> 
> Producing any other alternative outputs are an issue left to any consumer 
> level apps, their internationalization and localization libraries and 
> databases, so if you want to see alternative output, talk to your software 
> providers or vendors.
> 
> Source code patches to the data and libraries are gratefully accepted from 
> all contributors, but may be used only at the discretion of the maintainers, 
> who have to maintain the data and code for the benefit of all global users, 
> in their "copious" personal free time as volunteers.
> 
> For system level utilities like date, what is provided by the base libraries 
> is adequate for information and scripting, and if you want to see alternative 
> output, you can add a layer in some scripting language over the top of 
> date(1) or strftime(3), depending on what is supported by the chosen language.
> 
> For example:
> ```
> $ bash -c 'help printf'
> printf: printf [-v var] format [arguments]
>    Formats and prints ARGUMENTS under control of the FORMAT.
> ...
>    In addition to the standard format specifications described in printf(1),
>    printf interprets:
> ...
>      %(fmt)T  output the date-time string resulting from using FMT as a format
>               string for strftime(3)
> ```
> 
> -- 
> Take care. Thanks, Brian Inglis              Calgary, Alberta, Canada
> 
> La perfection est atteinte                   Perfection is achieved
> non pas lorsqu'il n'y a plus rien à ajouter  not when there is no more to add
> mais lorsqu'il n'y a plus rien à retrancher  but when there is no more to cut
>                                -- Antoine de Saint-Exupéry

Reply via email to