On Tue, 2006-10-03 at 21:05 -0700, Troy James Sobotka wrote: > On Tue, 2006-03-10 at 21:27 +0200, Eric Schwenke wrote: > > Sry for filling the mailing list, but in mind of some critic i have an > > updatet version of my set created. > > > > Changes: - Gloss effect like the human folder one (more consistent) > > - Added a orange color version, in mind of human consistent > > These are amazingly impressive. > > Strengths: > * Unified -- especially the orange set. > * Integration factor is very high - the curvature is perfect. > * Simple -- beautifully simplistic for a first draft. > > With a little discussion regarding some of the iconography, > I think they would be a wonderful addition to the current > set. > > This is probably the most consistent set of work that > I have seen since some of Who's, when considered against > the current "Ubuntu schema". > > > Sincerely, > TJS
Echo from me; these are really quite lovely. I only have three comments to make that is: (1) the 'cool', 'generic', 'oh-no!', 'share', 'urgent' and 'web' all have white "outlines", that is white circles before giving way to the final orange border. I can see why the 'web' one would be designed like this but the others I listed above in contrast the rest of the icons, it doesn't make sense. (2) Some of the icons have thinner and sharper lines/corners, while others don't. For example look at 'photos', 'cvs-modified', and 'mail'. Now compare them to something like 'presentation'. Maybe we should make sure the thickness of the lines are more similar and perhaps the same for a corner's sharpeness/acuteness. (3) Personally 'photos' and 'pictures' should be swapped, that is, 'photos' icon becomes the icon for 'pictures' and visa versa. Currently the icon for 'Pictures' reminds me more of a polaroid or some other form of photograph. :) If you want I can play around with them to illustrate what I mean. ...But overall, awesome work! -Pascal
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part
-- ubuntu-art mailing list [email protected] https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-art
