daniel planas armangue wrote: > uff, I do not like much. > > 1 - are highly disproportionate > 2 - a little tangoish > 3 - the use of the antenna does not fit sebastian > 4 - the colors are not very clean > > > however it is noted that time devoted to it, therefore I am going to > make a constructive criticism, inspired on this icon: > > http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2107/2412348459_218e4d1b2a.jpg?v=1208161662 > > I think most of the time will be seen in small-scale, therefore you need > think more on a glyph. > > Daniel .P > > > > > hi, i'm not sure if u are talking about the straight bars or the curved ones?
the first[straight bar] icons were just mockup , since i was not sure if the team was interested in a nm icon ... and i was new to inkscape hence i didnt know if the learning curve would be worth the while[since i had a working set of pngs for personal use and the whole set needed 38 icons...!] the mockup should probably even be considered just a doodle! i used the antennae purposefully ,just to maintain an aspect from the wireless-network icon. but on usage scaling down the presence/absence of the antennae doesnt matter. it can be removed... the image u have linked looks similar to the gnome colors icon,also similar to what i aim to achieve... if u check my first post ,https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-art/2009-May/010477.html, i have included a set of my working pngs which have a new reconnect animation behavior, the change in animation behavior is my main reason for suggestion of the nm icons, since the old hi-color icons dont look that great... even the second set i have uploaded are just a work in progress, Anyway Cory has suggested that he could help or get someone to make the icons fit better with the breathe set... i'm not sure if ur comments are regarding the first doodle set i had submitted in the first post or the second set i had uploaded to the wiki earlier today?just to be clear which set of icons were your comments about? any ideas/suggestion would be appreciated... or if someone can do it better too, welcome , i just feel nm needs a new look. :) cheers mac_v -- ubuntu-art mailing list [email protected] https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-art
