Bryce,

While I appreciate you adding the stored EDID data to the wishlist, and
your confirmation that corrupted EDID data is a factor here, I think the
essential point of the bug I was driving at may have gotten lost in the
shuffle. The main problem I'm having here is the behavior of xrandr,
which is reporting a disconnected display even though the display is
connected and active. The new title you gave this bug no longer
correctly reflects the central point.

It does not seem reasonable for the disconnected/connected status to be
"connected" only in cases where a monitor is both connected *and* EDID
data was captured correctly. Surely if the display is in use, it must be
connected for practical purposes.

Thank you for your courteous reply. I'd appreciate some clarification
from you on whether this behavior in xrandr is intended at present and
whether it might be changed. If the "disconnected" message is truly
considered correct, I can try to take the issue up with the maintainer
of xscreensaver.

This is the second time we've crossed paths -- the last time was about
my monitor's resolution settings not being detected properly, which was
no doubt due to the KVM's interference (see bug 180601 -- actually
*that* bug probably deserves this bug's new title). Thanks for your
continued dedication to improving Ubuntu.



** Summary changed:

- Omniport KVM corrupts monitor EDID for Sony Multiscan E200
+ xrandr reports display as 'disconnected' when EDID data not captured 
successfully, even if display in question is active and in use

-- 
xrandr reports display as 'disconnected' when EDID data not captured 
successfully, even if display in question is active and in use
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/313220
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to