I am here from a duplicate of this bug, and I see this issue as a huge deal.
my experience with this issue:

1) an upgrade of a production server at our co-location from dapper to
hardy resulted in botched grub settings, I am still digging through
backups to determine the contents of fstab prior to the upgrade.  After
the upgrade the fstab was pointed to the incorrect device (via uuid)
this resulted in an unbootable system and a 60 mile round trip drive out
to our co-location to rescue the machine. dist upgrades should not touch
my fstab, I like it just how it is. Neither should my operating system
determine what is best for me, there is other software I can pay for to
do that. I have grub configured just how I want it, please just move my
current options to the new grub menu item.

2) This evening I added two hard drives to my home server. In the
process of doing this, the UUID entries in both the grub menu and the
fstab created problems with the new hard drives (duplicate entries).
So, since /dev/ locations change so often that they are no longer
reliable, I too feel that UUIDs are non-reliable either. In the ubuntu
server distributions use of UUIDs should be disabled, and legacy /dev/
support should be re-inserted. Use of /dev/ locations on my home server
would have prevented the problems I experienced this evening.  Addition
and subtraction of USB and transient devices are not expected on server
hardware.

-- 
edgy update-grub destroys kopt
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/62195
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to