OK, so ran another side-by-side comparison this morning on two machines,
a macbook with running the BCM wl driver, and a macbook pro running
ath9k.   Both machines are Karmic RC + lastest updates.

I bumped the verbosity of wpa_supplicant logging ( added -d to the args
in the .service file ), wiped the daemon.log on both.  I then did the
following on both:

1. Associated with my home AP ( WEP )
2. Suspended both machines around 9:30 AM
3. Resumed both machines at around 10:15 AM at a local coffee shop

As expected, the ath9k machine displayed a Disconnected notification
dialog, whereas the wl machine started spinning the applet icon, and
eventually popped up a key / password dialog for my home AP.

I went through the logs side by side and they look almost identical,
except for the fact that the 'wl' driver never seems to generate a
disconnect wireless event on sleep.   This is what I expected.

As NM does have logic to deactivate and clear the currently associated
AP on sleep, I think the 'w' driver behavior is exposing a bug in  NM.

I'll attach sanitized versions of both logs.

-- 
[Broadcom wl]: After Resume, NM tries to connect to previous, non-available 
Wi-Fi network
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/452571
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to