Ok, we all agree that this is a bug. Nouveau has several issues (bug 553789 
being one of the rather grave ones that affect me personally) so just 
suggesting to use that rather than the nvidia driver doesn't help many of us. 
As for why plymouth is there: It functions as a message manager between the 
user and the asynchronous upstart system services which would fight for 
keyboard input and mix their messages without a manager which would be a total 
chaos. That's why simply getting rid of plymouth isn't really doable (don't ask 
me why they didn't postpone upstart instead, I don't know). Also, the change in 
natty was already tried in maverick, but back then it broke much more than it 
fixed so it was quickly reverted. Those issues were adressed by the parties 
involved so with natty this should look better.
Note that it is highly unlikely that those fixes will be backported to lucid 
and maverick. . While I agree that the text mode splash looks horrible and I 
passionately hate it, the risk is too high that trying to fix this in the 
stable releases would make the system unbootable for many (or it wouldn't have 
taken until natty to improve it).

I'm not a developer either, only a long time alpha tester that has
nvidia cards so don't ask me about more details there.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/563878

Title:
  Ubuntu splashscreen big and ugly after installing ATI/nVidia
  proprietary graphics driver

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to