Public bug reported:

Binary package hint: ubuntu-mono

Since the Ubuntu-Monochrome 0.0.26 upload, the battery status icon now
goes critical red with over an hour to spare.

We need to confirm this in Ayatana-Design, but my hunch is the following
would be more useful:

  external power: normal text colour (ivory/chocolate for Ambiance/Radiance)
  >=1:00 remaining: normal text colour
  < 1:00 remaining: orange non-critical warning
  <=0:10 remaining: red critical warning
  <=0:02 remaining: red critical warning if suspend/hibernate action selected 
and proven working
  <=0:02 remaining: red critical (flashing) warning if simply going to power-off

Additionally, the Ubuntu Mono 0.0.26 change uses a battery icon with no
fill for empty.  This is not as clear to the user as an icon that
instead uses a very small fill at end of the battery, even for zero.
This is more intuitive as it makes it clear that the icon is used as a
percentage indicator;  with an empty fill the user must already know
this for "empty" to be useful as a relative indicator.

At the moment, the "Red with some left" state seen at 1:10 remaining is
far more visible to the user than the (more serious) completely empty
icon.

** Affects: ayatana-design
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New

** Affects: ubuntu-mono (Ubuntu)
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New


** Tags: needs-design

** Also affects: ayatana-design
   Importance: Undecided
       Status: New

** Tags added: needs-design

** Description changed:

  Binary package hint: ubuntu-mono
  
  Since the Ubuntu-Monochrome 0.0.26 upload, the battery status icon now
  goes critical red with over an hour to spare.
  
  We need to confirm this in Ayatana-Design, but my hunch is the following
  would be more useful:
  
-   external power: normal text colour (ivory/chocolate for Ambiance/Radiance)
-   >=1:00 remaining: normal text colour
-   < 1:00 remaining: orange non-critical warning
-   <=0:10 remaining: red critical warning
-   <=0:02 remaining: red critical warning if suspend/hibernate action selected 
and proven working
-   <=0:02 remaining: red critical (flashing) warning if simply going to 
power-off
+   external power: normal text colour (ivory/chocolate for Ambiance/Radiance)
+   >=1:00 remaining: normal text colour
+   < 1:00 remaining: orange non-critical warning
+   <=0:10 remaining: red critical warning
+   <=0:02 remaining: red critical warning if suspend/hibernate action selected 
and proven working
+   <=0:02 remaining: red critical (flashing) warning if simply going to 
power-off
  
  Additionally, the Ubuntu Mono 0.0.26 change uses a battery icon with no
  fill for empty.  This is not as clear to the user as an icon that
  instead uses a very small fill at end of the battery, even for zero.
  This is more intuitive as it makes it clear that the icon is used as a
  percentage indicator;  with an empty fill the user must already know
- this for "empty" to be useful as a relative indicator.  At the moment
- for "Red with some left" seen at (on this laptop) 1:10 remaining is far
- more visible that the more serious empty icon.
+ this for "empty" to be useful as a relative indicator.
+ 
+ At the moment, the "Red with some left" state seen at 1:10 remaining is
+ far more visible to the user than the (more serious) completely empty
+ icon.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/743823

Title:
  Battery goes Critical Red with 1:10 battery left

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to