On 4/29/07, Paul Sladen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > This bug is hard to process because it's a policy issue (a question) > that needs to be decided: > > * Should USB insertion or Mouse movement cause wake-up on a > suspended/hibernated system?
Yes. > If there are other ways of resuming the laptop (eg. opening the lid, > pressing the power or Fn button), then this issue really a bug, but a > need to answer the above question. The use case I am describing is a suspend that is triggered by initiating suspend from the System --> Suspend menu. The lid of the laptop isn't closed in this instance. However, if I suspend and then close the lid and reopen it, the machine does resume. Obviously, this is suboptimal. > End of Policy issue, my own views: > > Personally (this is my own view and may not be correct), is that USB > wakeup by default would be a bad idea (a faulty USB device, or one that > resets itself, or a USB device that is unplugged and replugged at the > power-source would cause wakeup). I suspect that issues from faulty devices can all be resolved. In fact, this is a non-issue, because David Brownell has already submitted patches that cause USB to "just work" with wake-from-suspend. > Mouse/keyboard, I'm not so sure about. Many people have 'cats'. Wake-from-suspend as a result of keyboard and mousepad events is the default behavior for Windows XP. It is the expected behavior for standard users. We should provide the same, imho. -- Need /proc/acpi/wakeup tweaks to enable mousepad and USB to wake up from suspend https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/109446 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is the bug contact for Ubuntu. -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list [email protected] https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs
