Oliver: it's certainly true that the Unity work has evolved out of and
is a continuation of the Ubuntu Netbook Remix interface research work.
However, as the substantial user base are desktop users, it's fairly
unlikely that Ubuntu would be wishing to upset those existing users
intentionally—you note that folks introduced you to Ubuntu, and you
yourself encouraged more folks to follow after that.  It's likely that
you are all desktop users.

I'd like to explore your LTS concern(s).  Currently an LTS release is
supported for five years on the desktop (it used to be three years on
the desktop).  That means that what /was/ released, is going to be
supported going forward and continue to be usable, in a fully supported
fashion, for at least half a decade.  You've still obviously got some
concerns, or questions, around LTS and the desktop experience.  Could
you narrow those down specifically and I'll try and respond to them?

I believe at the recent UDS-P in Orlando, it was specifically mentioned
in Mark Shuttleworth's keynote that there would be a focus on "power
users" during the cycle.  The keynote section on power-users starts at
the following offset:

  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0bOwyGYTMv8#t=22m38s

Ubuntu's success to-date has generally been around choosing good
defaults.  You've asked the question "Can I tell it what language I
speak?"  It's more interesting to thing about the wider issue;  eg. "Can
the system make a educated, fairly reliable guess at what language(s) I
speak?".  The positioning of the Launcher is a similar one, it's where
it is because that's where other stuff isn't–position shuffling is not
that interesting;  instead it might be better to investigate from a
higher-level design perspective if the Launcher needs to exist at all.
Look at the wider puzzle rather than the narrow solution.

Adding options for the sake of it is bit like Henry Ford's "faster
horses" quote:

  If I'd asked customers what they wanted, they would have said "a
faster horse".

Ford successfully produced and marketed a product that the buyers had
not imagined before.  Suffice to say, horses still exist and have not
been wiped out as a result, instead the provision has allowed horses to
be optimised for their /current requirements/.

Bazon: What Mint have been doing with the GNOME 3 Shell MGSE extensions
is quite interesting and it's pleasing to see additional Linux
distributions start to take an interest in desktop design.  Ultimately
the work that both Mint and Ubuntu have been doing will roll back into a
better desktop experience for Free Software desktop users in the long-
run, as the various open projects and research cross-percolate.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/882274

Title:
  Community engagement is broken

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ayatana-design/+bug/882274/+subscriptions

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to