Public bug reported:

AppArmor is a Canonical supported project yet several of its binaries are in 
universe. Most of AppArmor is already in main; these are the binaries that are 
currently in universe:
 - apparmor-notify
 - apparmor-profiles
 - libpam-apparmor
 - libapache2-mod-apparmor
 - python-libapparmor

These binaries meet the main inclusion requirements:

Rationale: Their placement in universe is misleading and does not
reflect their level of support. Some people may choose to not use these
applications because of their placement in the archive, but we should be
encouraging people to use these, especially for our upcoming LTS.

Security: there are no CVEs in these packages. No daemons, no
setuid/setgid

Quality assurance:
 - no debconf questions higher than medium
 - most packages have no configuration. Ones that do have extensive 
documentation
 - no longstanding bugs affecting the package to a major degree
 - Package is supported: AppArmor upstream and the Ubuntu Security team treat 
these as if they were supported in main.
 - bugs track in Launchpad upstream project and Ubuntu
 - there are testsuites for these, and AppArmor meets the recent Acceptance 
Criteria with daily builds and distro tests
 - there is a debian/watch file

UI standards: command line

Dependencies: all in main (apparmor source and most of its binaries are
already in main)

Standards compliance: follows FHS, lintian clean with exception of one
manpage warning

Maintenance: these binaries are already supported by Ubuntu Security

** Affects: apparmor (Ubuntu)
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New

** Description changed:

  AppArmor is a Canonical supported project yet several of its binaries are in 
universe. Most of AppArmor is already in main; these are the binaries that are 
currently in universe:
-  - apparmor-notify
-  - apparmor-profiles
-  - libpam-apparmor
-  - libapache2-mod-apparmor
-  - python-libapparmor
+  - apparmor-notify
+  - apparmor-profiles
+  - libpam-apparmor
+  - libapache2-mod-apparmor
+  - python-libapparmor
  
  These binaries meet the main inclusion requirements:
  
  Rationale: Their placement in universe is misleading and does not
  reflect their level of support. Some people may choose to not use these
  applications because of their placement in the archive, but we should be
  encouraging people to use these, especially for our upcoming LTS.
  
- Security: there are no CVEs in these packages
+ Security: there are no CVEs in these packages. No daemons, no
+ setuid/setgid
  
  Quality assurance:
-  - no debconf questions higher than medium
-  - most packages have no configuration. Ones that do have extensive 
documentation
-  - no longstanding bugs affecting the package to a major degree
-  - Package is supported: AppArmor upstream and the Ubuntu Security team treat 
these as if they were supported in main. 
-  - bugs track in Launchpad upstream project and Ubuntu
-  - there are testsuites for these, and AppArmor meets the recent Acceptance 
Criteria with daily builds and distro tests
-  - there is a debian/watch file
+  - no debconf questions higher than medium
+  - most packages have no configuration. Ones that do have extensive 
documentation
+  - no longstanding bugs affecting the package to a major degree
+  - Package is supported: AppArmor upstream and the Ubuntu Security team treat 
these as if they were supported in main.
+  - bugs track in Launchpad upstream project and Ubuntu
+  - there are testsuites for these, and AppArmor meets the recent Acceptance 
Criteria with daily builds and distro tests
+  - there is a debian/watch file
  
  UI standards: command line
  
  Dependencies: all in main (apparmor source and most of its binaries are
  already in main)
  
  Standards compliance: follows FHS, lintian clean with exception of one
  manpage warning
  
  Maintenance: these binaries are already supported by Ubuntu Security
- 
- Security: these binaries have no CVE history. No daemons, no
- setuid/setgid

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/893266

Title:
  [MIR] move all apparmor binaries to main

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/apparmor/+bug/893266/+subscriptions

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to