I agree with Stanley that the solution needs to be mentioned at a
prominent place.

I suspect that the crucial point got lost in this long discussion: While
updates may work, any fresh installation of Xubuntu from the current CD
fails _always_!

Imagine a user new to Linux, who decides to give Xubuntu a try. He puts
in the CD, boots up, clicks on "install", does not have any special
wishes and hence always tells the installer to use the default option.
The installer will notice that there is free space on the hardd disk and
suggest to put an ext3 partition there, to which the user happily
agrees. The installation then aborts abruptly with a completely
unhelpful and misleading error message.

Our new user is be disappointed that a straight-forward vanilla install
on a completely ordinary PC fails. Being new to Ubuntu he does not know
about Community Support and simply reasons that this Xubuntu thingy is a
conpletely broken, badly maintained thing.

Ubuntu strives to be "Linux for the people", a distribution that simply
works and does not require any guru-style fiddling ot tweaking. A bug
like this: in the _installer_, striking _always_, making installation
_impossible_ without tricks, must be corrected immediatly.

Hence, I sincerely ask you to apply the patch directly to the the ISO
images for Xubuntu Feisty. I realize that replacing the ISO images is a
major trouble but it seems necessary. The next best solution would be to
put a link to an easily comprehensible explanation of the work-around
right next to the download link for the ISO image.

Cheers
   Simon


O

-- 
Xubuntu partitioning can fail because ubiquity does not prevent thunar from 
automounting new partitions
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/107259
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is the bug contact for Ubuntu.

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to