>>"This conclusion is flawed. When I install fglrx in Quantal, just as I
in Lucid, it should still work, in whatever implementation would be
supported/required. It doesn't."

Speaking of flawed conclusions, why would you believe this when
precedent shows the opposite? Going back to the Radeon X1600 example,
fglrx worked fine for that card in Hardy, but did not in Lucid, and AMD
never updated their 9-3 Legacy driver for use with newer kernels and
Xservers.

>>"I, and the rest of the Ubuntu Community, are only looking for the "It
just works." experience one comes to expect when using Ubuntu software
from the repositories."

The open-source driver works out of the box. If you absolutely must have
fglrx, then you'll have to use Precise, which is supported for 4 more
years.

>> "Please stop wasting my time asking me to file additional, frivolous 
>> reports. 
I'm asking you to file a valid report against the correct package that takes 
reality into account. The reality is that fglrx versions past 12-6 no longer 
support RadeonHD 2000-4000 (if you really don't believe me/phoronix or anyone 
but the AMD site, then apt-get source fglrx and look at the PCI ID's) and 
Ubuntu 12.10 uses code based on Catalyst 12-9 beta. So you're actually 100% 
correct that fglrx doesn't support your card (and no one's going to "fix" 
that). The best you can hope for is the legacy driver being updated to use 
newer kernels/Xservers.

>> "As well, please stop Status jockeying this report. It's valid, unless the 
>> maintainers say otherwise."
I would encourage you to stop changing the status, but I can see that the "you 
can lead a horse to water, but can't make it drink" adage probably applies 
here. Your bug is "won't fix" at best, but it seems you can't accept that 
reality. Good luck with that....
"The truth does not need your participation to exist" - Terrence McKenna

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1069299

Title:
  1002:9613 fglrx-installer not working in Quantal

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/fglrx-installer/+bug/1069299/+subscriptions

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to