Since I was looking at this anyway, I ran a quick seeded-in-ubuntu test on the current list.
This was mostly done using "for pkg in $(cat list); do seeded-in-ubuntu $pkg | grep "^ " | grep -v ubuntu-touch -q && echo $pkg; done" where "list" is the list in the bug description. Then ignoring any complaint about non-existing packages and re-checking all entries by hand to ignore false positives (-dbg files, experimental images that are safe to ignore, ...) After kicking out false-positives, the following probably need extra discussion: - qt-gstreamer (multiple binaries seeded by kubuntu) - tinyxml (multiple binaries seeded by kubuntu) - schroedinger (multiple binaries seeded by kubuntu, lubuntu and ubuntu) - bridge-utils (seeded in edubuntu and part of ubuntu-server) - cgroup-lite (seeded in edubuntu and part of ubuntu-server) - gstreamer0.10-ffmpeg (multiple binaries seeded by kubuntu) - libav (multiple binaries seeded by kubuntu, lubuntu, ubuntu and ubuntustudio) - libgsm (one binary seeded by lubuntu) - libva (one binary seeded by lubuntu) - libhybris (multiple binaries seeded by edubuntu, kubuntu, lubuntu and ubuntu) As one of the usual uploaders for bridge-utils and cgroup-lite, I'll kick them out of the list in the description since I don't want anyone doing feature upload of those without having a serious discussion with the release team. Note that the list above is probably inaccurate (missing entries) as for some reason Edubuntu appears to be seeding most of the ubuntu-touch stuff at the moment (not sure why), so I had to clear a lot of those by hand and probably missed a few in the process. ** Description changed: Dear Release Team, I would like to request a blanket FFe wrt Ubuntu Touch, for those packages that are part of Ubuntu Touch but not part of Ubuntu Desktop. TTBOMK, the packages that are different between the two are not otherwise used in other flavor images, but let me know if you would like me to check this explicitly. I've assembled a list of 101 source packages, included inline below, that would be affected by this. The script used to generate the list is included at the bottom. For the vast majority of these packages, there is no expectation of freeze-breaking changes; but since there is a high probability that some critical features will not be landed by Feature Freeze for some subset of these packages, I think it makes sense to deal with these as a whole rather than requesting exceptions package-by-package or feature-by- feature. A couple other notes: - Not all of the packages listed here are currently in the archive. Some of them are in ppas used for building Ubuntu Touch. We have committed to fixing this by the end of the week by moving any necessary packages into the archive. - Some of the packages - in particular, the "*-app" packages - will not be moving to the archive at all because they are expected to transition to click packages. Although these "core apps" will not be part of the main Ubuntu archive, they nevertheless will be shipped on an Ubuntu image, so I think need to be dealt with via the usual community processes (including freeze handling). Does this sound reasonable? abootimg accounts-qml-module address-book-app address-book-service android-audiosystem android-tools apparmor-easyprof-ubuntu - bridge-utils calendar-app camera-app - cgroup-lite click click-apparmor dee-qt demo-assets-music demo-assets-scopes demo-assets-shell demo-assets-videos dropping-letters friends-app gallery-app gsettings-qt gsettings-ubuntu-touch-schemas gstreamer0.10-ffmpeg initramfs-tools-ubuntu-touch libav libgsm libhud-qt libhybris libpinyin libqtfolks1 libsynthesis libusermetrics libva lxc-android-config maliit-framework maliit-plugins mediaplayer-app music-app notes-app ofono ofono-qt ofono-scripts phone-app platform-api powerd presage python-gnupg qdjango qmenumodel qml-friends qtdeclarative5-konsole-qml-plugin qtdeclarative5-nemo-qml-plugin-folderlistmodel qt-gstreamer qtubuntu qtubuntu-camera qtubuntu-media qtubuntu-media-signals qtubuntu-sensors qtvideo-node schroedinger share-app stock-ticker-mobile-app sudoku-app syncevolution system-image telepathy-logger-qt5 telepathy-ofono telepathy-qt5 tinyxml ubuntu-calculator-app ubuntu-clock-app ubuntu-download-manager ubuntu-filemanager-app ubuntu-rssreader-app ubuntu-system-settings python-gnupg qdjango qmenumodel qml-friends qtdeclarative5-konsole-qml-plugin qtdeclarative5-nemo-qml-plugin-folderlistmodel qt-gstreamer ubuntu-system-settings-online-accounts ubuntu-terminal-app ubuntu-touch-generic-initrd ubuntu-touch-meta ubuntu-touch-session ubuntu-ui-toolkit ubuntu-weather-app unity8 unity-action-api unity-greeter-session-broadcast unity-lens-mock unity-notifications unity-scope-click upstart-app-launch webapps-demo webbrowser-app $ wget http://cdimage.ubuntu.com/daily-live/pending/saucy-desktop-amd64.manifest $ wget http://cdimage.ubuntu.com/ubuntu-touch/daily-preinstalled/pending/saucy-preinstalled-touch-armhf.manifest $ for F in $(sed -e's/[:[:space:]].*//' saucy-desktop-amd64.manifest); do grep-dctrl -X -n -FPackage -sSource:Package $F /var/lib/apt/lists/*saucy*binary-armhf_Packages | head -n 1; done | sort -u > saucy-desktop-sources $ for F in $(sed -e's/[:[:space:]].*//' saucy-preinstalled-touch-armhf.manifest); do G=$(grep-dctrl -X -n -FPackage -sSource:Package $F /var/lib/apt/lists/*saucy*binary-armhf_Packages | head -n 1); if [ -z "$G" ]; then G=$F; fi; echo $G; done | sort -u > saucy-touch-sources $ join -j1 -v2 saucy-desktop-sources saucy-touch-sources -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1208989 Title: [FFe] standing freeze exception for Ubuntu Touch-specific packages To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/1208989/+subscriptions -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs