As a parting comment, this was awful enough and lasted long enough that
I was forced to drop 6450s in the affected hardware, so I don't know if
any of that was resolved.

I will note the following for those in the same boat:

a) Dropping in Radeon 6450s did solve it and they were "only" $30 or so
with careful shopping at that time, probably less now that they only
have half the performance of an A8's integrated GPU.

b) Dropping in 6450s did generate enough heat and power stress in
combination to take out the aged capacitors in one of the two machines,
forcing an upgrade, which forced the issue of upgrading the other
machine to match.  If you're upgrading an old machine with a fanless
card and there's no case fan in the usual "near the card cage" position,
I would suggest adding one for the extra $4 or so for insurance or
rubber-chicken facto.  At least, in my minimal sample of these 2
machines and 2 similar Socket AM2 boxes with case fans (~80-90mm low-RPM
'silent' types) it was only one of the fanless boxes that hit death.  (I
will also note that the dead box had a standard 'old fashioned' power
supply with a small exhaust fan and mostly slots on the back, while the
boxes with no trouble have all had the 'modern' style with a large 120mm
fan pulling air up across the board from the bottom.  In a marginal
situation this might be enough to keep things alive until the hardware
is obsolete for other reasons.)

c) Fingers crossed, thus far I have not been bitten with too much bitrot
in the 6450 support and I believe they are recent enough to still be a
target for the ongoing improvements in the open-source driver.. this
year, at least.  fglrx still supports them right now.

d) If I had realized Socket FM2 was a dead-end at the time I ended up
having to buy new machines as a result of this saga, I would've been
even more annoyed.  If something's gone wrong now and you're still
standing by AMD, do make sure you end up with something FM2+ (not plain
FM2) so upgrades to anything interesting will be possible.

The Unity/Libre/Firefox stack has been gradually bloating such that the
maximum 2GB in the old machines was not going to support standard
browsing/multiple-documents-and-reference-PDFs-open-at-once office tasks
for much longer anyway.

It is never fun to be forced to upgrade hardware solely for reasons of
bitrot.  While I think AMD ex-ATI has better intentions of providing
good and stable FOSS/*NIX support for chips of roughly the vintage of
the 6450 and later, and I sure appreciate what a nightmare maintaining
X.org support must be (I was also 'bitten' by the rot of support for the
'well-supported' Matrox G200 at the end of the AGP era)... I will post
grumpily grumpy about this to the extent that it might shame anyone into
not letting the decay repeat quite so badly in the future.  (There
seemed to be initial good intentions with the RS480 and 780G, but
breakage in support for both forced me to invest in a lot of 6450s...
even when they had previously been quite adequate and the only "3D" app
in use was Unity itself.  It does leave the customer feeling like a
sucker and I can no longer say I've had no problems maintaining a
business on AMD... even if I did get to sit out a dozen different
incompatible Intel CPU socket 'generations' in the time this hardware
lasted, and enjoy switching from the original Semprons to some of the
last Athlon 64x2 parts when the former could no longer cut it.)

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1181355

Title:
  R300 (RS480): Intermittent flickering corruption top half of display
  (VGA, 1080p)

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/xserver-xorg-video-ati/+bug/1181355/+subscriptions

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to