** Description changed: [Impact] Ceph from ubuntu trusty, the version is 0.80.*. The bug is that when a message seq number has exceeds the max value of unsigned 32 bit which is 4294967295, the unsigned 64 bit seq number will be truncated to unsigned 32 bit. But the seq number is supposed to increase one by one, and if messenger got a message which has an old seq number, it will just drop it. when it dropped one sub_op/sub_op reply message, then this operation will not be able to succeed, it will become a slow request. cluster will suffering from slow requests when it hits this bug. when it drops other message, might lead to other bad situation ( like droping osd_ping message might cause the osd down). [Test case] Deploy a trusty ceph cluster Two ways to reproduce, A will take at least 2 months to reproduce, B will be much easier: A. 1. ceph daemon osd.<id> set config debug_ms 10 2. wait for the seq number to increasing to max value of unsigned 32 bit value which is 4294967295, we can get the current seq number by doing command "grep "reader got message" /var/log/ceph/ceph-osd/ceph-osd.id.log" 3. you will finally see the messenger will drop message and see below log "reader got old message 0 <= 4294967295 0x7fa6854a3e00 osd_sub_op_reply(client.125216.1:7850657018 3.dc e24410dc/rb.0.103e.238e1f29.000000000027/head//3 [] ondisk, result = 0) v2, discarding " B. 1. ceph daemon osd.<id> set config debug_ms 10 2. gdb attach <pid of ceph-osd> 3. set a breakpoint at function Pipe::writer and set a command "set out_seq=4294967295" to this breakpoint 4. continue the process, when it hit the breakpoint multiple times (osd number - 1), we can exit the gdb. - 5. grep other osds log and see if you find message dropping message like : + 5. grep other osds log and see if you can find message dropping log like : "reader got old message 0 <= 4294967295 0x7fa6854a3e00 osd_sub_op_reply(client.125216.1:7850657018 3.dc e24410dc/rb.0.103e.238e1f29.000000000027/head//3 [] ondisk, result = 0) v2, discarding " [Regression Potential] None [Original Bug Report] When in_seq is 0xffffffff, Pipe::reader expects the incoming message's sequence to be 0x100000000. But m->get_seq() return 0. So the incoming message gets dropped. https://tracker.ceph.com/issues/16122
-- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1798081 Title: ceph got slow request because of primary osd drop messages To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ceph/+bug/1798081/+subscriptions -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs
